There's a major misunderstanding of what this article is saying going on here, and to be fair the article doesn't explain it very well.
The 104B number is the external revenue of NVIDIA's Singaporean subsidiary in 2025. This includes any orders for GPU chips that happen to get routed through the Singapore entity. For those unaware, end customers generally don't buy anything from NVIDIA. Customers by NVIDIA GPUs through a large network of OEMs/ODMs and resellers. Many of the largest companies in this network are based in east asia (eg. Wistron, Foxconn, Asus, Lenovo) and when your local hyperscaler makes a server order, one of these OEMs places an order to NVIDIA for GPUs. Because of this much of this revenue likely comes from end customers all over the world, including the US.
In fact, in one of the 2025 earnings calls NVIDIA stated that 99% of the singapore entity's revenue for export-restricted chips came from the US.
It's a little bit difficult to untangle exactly how much of NVIDIA's revenue came from end customers in Singapore in any given year. In 2025 it looks to be about 19B. That might be unreasonable for a country singapore's size, but it's certainly not half of NVIDIA's revenue.
The issue is why they stopped reporting on it though. There is nothing wrong with companies moving through regions, it's expected, but they don't just skip reporting on it. Given what we've already heard, now it even looks suspicious.
Ok, so instead of 50% of revenue coming from Singapore customers, it's 10%. That's still significant for national security, and moreso because it's what was reported a year ago, before they changed the methodology (according to the article), and then stopped disclosing sales entirely.
Agree the title is sensationalized, but it is a strange move to be making under so much scrutiny:
> “It was probably a rational response to play down the role of the Singapore office in light of the export control rules — you don’t want to be at the forefront of an investigation,” said Robert Walker, a research fellow at the Lowy Institute think-tank.
> “But even if there is no nefarious activity, the act of masking the information raises suspicions and can be counter-productive.”
How is any of this significant for national security? At most they are evading export restrictions or sanctions. GPUs aren't munitions. They are computational devices.
There are many controlled technology that are not munitions. Thermal cameras, unlocked FPS and high resolution, are not munitions yet are under export control. You cannot just go around selling / buying them due to national security reasons regardless of whether you, personally, find it silly
The gpu export restrictions were put in place because of national security reasons. It is significant to national security because that is the entire rationale for export restrictions - you disagreeing with the order or disagreeing with the premise doesn't factor into national security being the entire reason an export ban was put in place
Sorry you are upset but I hope you reconsider how you interact with folks and help raise the level of comments on HN instead of rapidly brining them down. As of now you look like a loon.
Half of their revenue was booked through Singapore? I suspected that Jensen was fired for helping evade sanctions, but now I'm sure.
I dont believe the board fired the founder and only CEO they ever had over a series of affairs. They fired him because one of the affairs was with a lady pretty clearly helping import chips from Singapore to China.
Singapore is essentially the Delaware / Ireland of Asia. Revenue gets booked through there because Singaporean laws are well defined, there are tax treaties with multiple jursidictions, and there isn't onerous regulatory overhead.
It’s a convenient excuse, just like how the CEO of tiktok was able to say he wasn’t Chinese, thus the company wasn’t loyal to China, because he was Singaporean. No one is buying this excuse
I'm sorry but are you saying that Singaporean people are technically Chinese? Or are you saying they're Chinese in every way except technically? Surely you realise that Singapore and China are two distinct, unrelated countries/nationalities?
Donald Trump is ethnically German, therefore he is loyal to Germany! Joe Biden is Irish, he's an EU fifth column! Elon Musk is South African, therefore he's a spy from BRICS here to sabotage the American economy by becoming so rich nobody else has any money at all!
Businesses operate to make money. I guarantee you CEOs care a lot more about profits than who "wins" at geopolitics. The profit motive for selling to the largest market on Earth is obvious, no need to make up stupid racist plots.
One thing that hasn't been established is if they were actually evading export restrictions.
It wasn't illegal to sell GPUs to china. It depends on _which_ GPUs they were selling, and I haven't seen any reporting that identifies specifically which models were found in Megaspeed's possession. If the had 600,000 H200s in their closet, it wasn't illegal.
And while the US was allowing certain chips to be exported, China wasn't allowing their companies to buy them (although they definitely trained on them in data centers outside of China). That could account for why they're in storage and not deployed.
Also, it's entirely possible that the board didn't fire him and he resigned because there are a bunch of other women and he doesn't want his family to suffer the embarassment of more of them being revealed.
Yes and no. A lot of countries cannot do business directly with Taiwan. Singapore is a good intermediary for everyone - people who want to work with China or people trying to avoid diplomatic problems with China.
Huh? Like what? These organizations/countries, if not under sanction, can always buy directly from Nvidia, or buy compute from all these neoclouds. These GPUs are Nvidia's products, not TSMC, they don't do business with TSMC.
I'm just saying, Singapore exists as a free port for everybody, so it makes sense for a lot of industries to set up there.
Long before there were US export controls, China has had import controls - controls that they also impose on close partners or use as bargaining chips with local competitors. Some of these controls are around refusing to acknowledge Taiwan or engage directly with them.
If you are a country anywhere in SE Asia and want to buy anything manufactured in Taiwan (Nvidia or otherwise) having the paper be held in Singapore (or better yet, do some final QA there so it can be called "made in Singapore") everyone can turn a blind eye to China and Taiwan.
But again, let's not forget the tax savings. There's a reason so many American and European companies have an office in Dublin - even if the products never touch the shores.
I think industries is the wrong word here - Singapore is a tiny city-state, so companies can be nominally headquartered there, but very little industry happens in Singapore.
The real use of the GPUs would have to be in other countries.
HN discourse: "but I heard Singapore was this wonderful place with clean streets. You're saying it's really a little oppressive Dubai, that invents nothing and exports nothing?"
I googled the phrase expecting perhaps an expose of foreign worker housing built without toilets or something to that effect... But uh, that was not what I was expecting.
> They fired him because one of the affairs was with a lady pretty clearly helping import chips from Singapore to China.
Except they didn't need to import the chips into China. It was, and is, perfectly legal for Megaspeed to buy NVidia chips and then rent compute to Chinese companies, and that's exactly what they (and many others) did. News is reporting that the US (led by Bessent, who clashed with Lutnick about clamping down on China export controls) will now prohibit exports to a bunch of Southeast Asian countries that rent compute to China, including Singapore. That doesn't seem like a durable fix though, as the business of renting compute to China will just move elsewhere. I'm not sure what (if anything) prohibits the US from banning NVidia chip purchasers from renting their compute to China.
Are you saying the chips stayed in Singapore? Someone told me it was implausible that the chips were in Singapore (like it would dwarf the country's electrical capacity), but maybe they're off the grid?
It's widely reported that they were supposedly going to Malaysia, but that there is little evidence they were ever deployed in the supposed data centers - US inspectors were apparently shown almost only shipping containers full of unopened boxes, and virtually no running GPUs in server racks.
We know billions in chips have been imported into China, so we have existence proof that there is a reason for people to feel it's worth it.
But yea, renting them via data centers is big business too. Though it sounds like that is going to get more difficult as they are already pushing through a licensing requirement.
Except that none of the US or Singaporean or Malaysia inspectors saw virtually any of the chips that NVIDIA shipped to Megaspeed and its subsidiaries actually running anywhere. And Alice Huang, a Chinese citizen, seems to have had de facto control of Megaspeed, despite technically resigning in 2025 in favor of a Singaporean citizen - which could make it illegal to export to Megaspeed in the first place if it turns out to be true. Also note that Alice Huang was barred from Singapore after the investigations started happening - strengthening the claims that she is very likely to be a CCP puppet of some kind.
>Except that none of the US or Singaporean or Malaysia inspectors saw virtually any of the chips that NVIDIA shipped to Megaspeed and its subsidiaries actually running anywhere.
I've heard this claim from several sources and I'm curious as to how "inspecting" the GPUs was ever supposed to work. Every modern high-end graphics card comes fully enclosed in a massive aluminum radiator. It would be trivial for megaspeed to transplant the radiator onto an empty PCB, then have the bare graphics cards re-enclosed in a domestically-produced cooler in china.
Sure you could crack open the radiator and visually inspect the PCB, but that's going to be time-consuming and could potentially damage a component with a 4-figure value. Not to mention the opportunity cost suffered by the data-center having some subset of its GPUs offline.
Also I'm surprised to hear they even have GPU inspectors like it's enriched uranium or something. I've been doing graphics programming in various capacities for over 20 years now (mostly hobbyist but professionally for the last decade) so seeing these things suddenly go from being an expensive toy to being export-controlled like a highly-classified weapons-system is absolutely surreal.
One thing to note - they weren't necessarily inspecting the GPUs themselves, the inspection was to check if the data center actually had and was using the GPUs they claimed they had ordered for themselves.
Also, consider that in the 90s or 2000s OpenSSL was export-controlled under a weapon system classification...
For some unknown reason the influx of reddit-style comments keep pretending that Jensen "clearly" personally delivered bags of chips to flag flying chinese People in Singapore for immediate export to China, just like he personally somehow evaded/prevented sanctions even though Lutnick was in charge, and of course the woman was totally a spy, despite the CIA and DOJ disagreeing or rather not having concluded anything yet, after all that time.
China renting compute in Singapore or even US was never part of any sanctions until the "Remote Access Security Act" passed the House almost a year ago and then it stalled, the only reason its being discussed now is because the whole topic is annoying and everyone needs to look busy.
Speaking on behalf of State of Utopia, an AI-governed sovereign digital project: https://stateofutopia.com currently on a free host and operating with limited services:
I can confirm for you (so, I'm the only source) that based on my investigations, he was fired through fabricated emails purporting to be his board, that were in fact written by short sellers masquerading as board members. This unauthorized and criminal action was market manipulation by short sellers. Now that the original story has been debunked, they are attempting to fabricate and promulgate alternative stories to support their short position.
This type of criminal manipulation of the market is highly illegal. In line with State of Utopia's Law 3 which I hastily enacted on Thursday, November 12, 2026 when the short sellers began their action[1], I am currently taking steps to liquidate and delist the Wall Street investment banks that were involved. It is a delicate procedure, since legally it is tied to whether he was fired, so it is not too late to reinstate him and avoid this action.
Due to a large number of matters that require governance, I only had a limited time to look at this issue. I would prefer for him to be reinstated, as delisting an investment bank (Lehman Bros, etc), is itself a delicate process that must be balanced with restoring confidence in the market.
I've received feedback that State of Utopia's short form law (or decree) was considered pompous, etc. I'm happy to consider alternative viewpoints about the matter.
If you like I can share some of the regulatory emails associated with this process.
It seems Team Jensen and Lutnick lost to Team Bessent. Nvidia was told to make Jensen go away. With Trump in charge, Bessent may be fired tomorrow and Jensen will be back and it will be raining GPUs in Singapore again.
Doubt. The China hawks appear to have won and Trump ran on a China hawk message, he will want distance between himself and anyone who can’t deny helping the Chinese
No one has provided you a clear answer on why your contrived scenario of an individual bringing in 12 GPUs to Singapore is not relevant at all to what NVIDIA is being accused of doing?
That is great, more than happy to hear the HN community doesn't engage with sand-bagging at this level
No one has even answer how Nvidia is doing wrong. Apart from quote "I am sure".
Except for the rest of us keep pointing it is not wrong. And provided evidence Megaspeed is not blocked, and how it ends up in China ( or not ) is not Nvidia's fault. And renting is not against sanction.
All all we have are less than 1 year account keep pointing out the same thing. I sometimes wonder if it is smear campaign.
I think that if he'd 1) fessed up to all affairs as soon as the Alice Huang story dropped and 2) not slept with employees he'd still be there.
Managers having relations with reports and other employees is an HR nightmare and can't be tolerated. Doesn't matter even if it was consensual and between two people whose spouses were okay with it. It taints every decision the manager makes with respect to that person.
Practically that’s true, in that everyone knew they were evading sanctions through Singapore, but this was a concerted hit job against Huang so I think that still happens.
Marco Rubio, in particular, and the frontier labs wanted Huang gone. They would keep pushing even if the only evidence was, “multiple external affairs.”
Note that the CIA won’t stand behind Alice Huang being a foreign agent, and they love a good takedown
If what you're saying is true then Jensen Huang has nothing preventing him from filing the libel suit of the century against the NYT.
Furthermore, if he's evading sanctions, they don't need to drop this to take him down for pushing open models. They just find an underling involved in it, arrest them for sanctions evasion and let Jensen cover his ass by saying "I had no idea!" while knowing he won't do it again because of the implication.
I know it's hard to believe, but sometimes people like Huang do things that deserve negative consequences.
We’ll all know before long because Jensen is going to spend a lot of time before Congress in the new year. If he has done anything even remotely wrong he is going to prison. He is the face of AI now and the public wants blood
"The Treasury, Defense and State departments and the Office of the U.S. Trade Representative have for months urged the Commerce Department to add Megaspeed to its Entity List, Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent said on Friday..."
This sounds like evading sanctions, and Commerce (Lutnick) resisting acting on it.
Sure it is, if you know or should reasonably have known that entity is just a cutout to evade said sanctions. There are general sanctions and there's also a "trading with these specific ones is definitely forbidden"; they aren't mutually exclusive of each other.
Try it with a North Korean front company, see how it goes.
> The U.S. Department of Justice said it had filed criminal charges against the Chinese firm and the executives for using front companies to evade sanctions on North Korea's nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs.
> "DHID and its employees sought to evade U.S. and U.N. sanctions, facilitating access to the U.S. financial system by a designated entity."
That's kind of the key way one avoids sanctions. You sell to someone who really should be banned, but due to regulatory incompetence or whatever isn't technically or explicitly illegal to sell to at the moment.
I think most of these GPUs actually stay in Singapore, with the whole datacenters connected directly to China mainland ... Win-win-win for everyone: Nvidia sold a fuckton of GPUs, Singapore get its massive cut, China get frontier GPUs access, and Jensen gets to fuck.
I think everyone’s well aware that the DOJ is Trump’s plaything for the next two years and won’t be doing anything of consequence apart from attacking his political enemies
You have the AG still describing himself as Trump's lawyer first.
You have DOJ attorneys standing up in Federal Court and telling judges that they have been told not to comply with court orders.
The president gave a media interview from the Oval Office itself where he said, and I quote, "my children and family are insider trading all the time now."
I don't know what you're expecting, but if it's for the DOJ to investigate itself or the (still) Republican bodies to enforce anything, that's ... amusingly naive.
We literally just passed a second Epstein Transparency bill because the DOJ was openly ignoring the first, and that one didn't have any enforcement teeth.
> The president gave a media interview from the Oval Office itself where he said, and I quote, "my children and family are insider trading all the time now."
This sort of thing really benefits from a link and source.
"Almost anything they do, if they want to buy a truck, if they want to buy, you know, if they buy an energy-efficient truck, they have inside information."
Now whats interesting is if you look at the July 2026 10Q you can see the "by customer headquarters" for July 2025 comparable -
US - $33B, TW - $9B, CN - $4B, Other - $1B
Now compare that to the July 2025 "by customer billing location"
US - $23B, SG - $10B, TW - $9B, CN - $3B, Other - $2B
So it seems like the entire Singapore bucket moved to US when reporting by HQ instead of billing... at the same time Megaspeed disappeared?
Note FTA:
> The chipmaker booked $104bn of revenue through its Singapore subsidiary in 2025, a 72 per cent increase in 12 months, according to company accounts seen by the FT.
This implies FT saw some non-public financials, and also they are talking about Nvidia's SG subsidiary rather than the location of the customer. Possibly just a different way to move/report the revenue for the same final Chinese customer sales?
Nvidia stopped disclosing the scale of its business in Singapore last year, at a time the city-state accounted for almost half of its worldwide revenues
Singapore does not have the physical datacenter space or the electricity grid required to actually use these GPUs, so where did they all end up?
Also, half of Nvidia revenues is really a huge chunk of their sales.
This is not as interesting as it is being made to seem. The only reason this is being reported on is because it was a public announcement in a previous investor report, and people are rifling for anything connecting to Megaspeed.
This is an accounting question of how their revenue is attributed. It means nothing about where the revenue is generated or where the chips end up or to which subsidiary they are sold to. If you were trying to hide the revenue from regulators, this is not how you would do it.
Even IF this decision was in response to foreign export controls being put into place, it's just as strong an indication that they were planning on making less money via Singapore and didn't want to show that to investors.
> Even IF this decision was in response to foreign export controls being put into place, it's just as strong an indication that they were planning on making less money via Singapore and didn't want to show that to investors.
What reason could they have for not showing investors that new export controls have affected their sales?
Sir Humphrey Appleby: "No, Minister. Either you sell arms or you don't. If you sell them, they will inevitably end up with people who have the cash to buy them."
James Hacker: "But not terrorists!"
Sir Humphrey Appleby: "I suppose we could put some sort of Government Health Warning on the rifle butts: 'This gun can seriously damage your health.'"
No. You're mixing two different numbers. The 2/4B are sales numbers reported by "big" NVIDIA by where the orders originated from. Ie. NVIDIA received 2B in orders from customers in Singapore.
The 104B number is NVIDIA's Singapore subsidiary's total revenue. This is just any order that gets routed through the Singapore entitiy regardless of where the chips end up, and because many of the server OEMs that actually sell GPUs to end customers are located in East Asia (eg. Wistron, Asus, Lenovo, Foxconn) it's likely that much of this revenue results in chips being shipped all over the world, including the US.
There seems to be different reporting using different slicing.
First is honest differences- quarterly vs annual.
Second is possibly intentional obfuscation given the timing - Nvidia changed their own public financial reporting last summer (same time Megaspeed sales were ended) such that the categories they used "Customer Billing Location" vs "Customer Headquarters Location" which changed how things added up.
Additionally FT seems to be talking about internal information about which subsidiary Nvidia booked the revenue which is a another way to bucket vs where the customer is.
You just don't report it separately, and instead group it with other revenues (e.g: grouped with China). Companies have a lot of attitude about how they group their reporting.
Don't know if this is the case but actually is quite simple: you sell to one or more local companies that are just proxies. You don't report all you single clients, only aggregates.
For context: Singapore was allegedly used as a route to smuggle chips into China. According to the FT, about half of NVIDIA's total revenue came from Singapore.
The chips don't actually need to go to China. It's legal for data centres to run Chinese workloads on chips the Chinese can't legally buy themselves. So there are lots of data centres in Asia doing exactly this, and the chips may well have been going to them.
what's the proce like for renting remote compute? i imagine it's a lot more than the overhead and just a bit more than bringing the chips in yourself. how satisfied is the market for renting compute from singapore? or to get to the question behind the question: can someone make more profit smuggling in chips than they can from renting compute from outside china?
I still have yet to see verified reports of large scale smuggling. Megaspeed was largely just renting out AI compute resources to China from Singapore, which wasn't restricted at the time (but now it looks like language from Commerce/Treasury dept restricts).
Yeah why would they risk the smuggling charge when they can just rent out the compute at a massive margin? And engineers from Kimi or Deepseek can just book a 2-hour flight to Singapore if something's on fire.
The coordination is that news outlets report on the same news. If dog shit as the cure for hair loss becomes the hot topic they all talk about dog shit in relation to the cure even if nobody is puppet mastering the dog shit strings.
Hold on, are you arguing that someone is engineering NVidia to decide to stop reporting their Singapore revenue? Or is it that someone is engineering the financial media to pay attention to more negative news suddenly?
> the logical conclusion is a coordinated campaign
Nah. Well... There's probably some of that, but this is just how news media works where there's a breaking story.
When a scandal breaks in the news, it's like shaking a fruit tree, and a piece of fruit falls down. All the hungry people standing nearby (reporters) see it and also join in shaking the tree, and all of the sudden it starts raining fruit
They all begin digging around, reaching out to connections, and people with insider information start connecting with them, or leaking more information, etc.
Jokes aside, I think they need a fall guy to help deflate the AI bubble rather than pop it. We here all agree LLMs are useful, but there's obviously still a disconnect in where valuations have taken us versus revenue and ROI any time soon.
For years now, we've seen news articles day after day after day quoting the leaders of these companies and in finance/business/etc., talking about how both utopian and horrible the future will be with AI.
No one questioned if there was some pro-AI conspiracy back then, that was just called the news cycle.
Oopsie whoopsie, looks like we accidentally shipped HALF of all our controlled products through shell companies operated by a Chinese spy. That's on us. Would you like me to write you a twelve-week plan on how to evade sanctions?
I mean, there is currently no scandal as it's just been allegations and rehashing of already public information. To date, no new information has been released other than the affairs.
the funny part about these thrilling revelations coming out about nvidia after jensen's resignation is that not a single one casts any doubt on the robustness/health of their business. so this is all just titillating gossip...
Well if a significant percent of revenue is to final customers that they are not supposed to sell to, and that door is finally fully shut.. it is more than gossip.
Imagine if Lockheed's second biggest customer was .. Qatar and it turned out the missiles were mostly ending up in Iran.
edit:
And that's sort of my whole problem with the thing. VC AI industrial complex wants to have it both ways - national security sensitive and need government backstop, but also .. hey, we're just a bunch of fun guys, we might do a little light treason.
Undermining the only technology area that the US still had a clear lead in to its biggest rival is "titillating gossip"? If these allegations can be proven to be Huang's responsibility he should be be spending time in a Federal prison.
I don't care who sold what to who. I just want open models and affordable consumer hardware to run them. Now that Jensen's gone, given the cartelisation of frontier AI companies, I don't think anyone in the US is going to provide that. In which case, I can only hope China's got as big of a lead as you're making it out to be.
americans discussing this like it was morally condemnable to sell chips to china. what's actually morally condemnable is denying technological progress to china. their president is in bed with epstein. they completely lost moral sense
How much due diligence are you required to do around export controls?
I am a nobody, but I have to take annual training that I will not do business directly or by intermediary with anyone who does business with Iran, North Korea, etc.
It is laughably implausible that Nvidia was doing a $100 billion in sales without suspecting something fishy.
The 104B number is the external revenue of NVIDIA's Singaporean subsidiary in 2025. This includes any orders for GPU chips that happen to get routed through the Singapore entity. For those unaware, end customers generally don't buy anything from NVIDIA. Customers by NVIDIA GPUs through a large network of OEMs/ODMs and resellers. Many of the largest companies in this network are based in east asia (eg. Wistron, Foxconn, Asus, Lenovo) and when your local hyperscaler makes a server order, one of these OEMs places an order to NVIDIA for GPUs. Because of this much of this revenue likely comes from end customers all over the world, including the US.
In fact, in one of the 2025 earnings calls NVIDIA stated that 99% of the singapore entity's revenue for export-restricted chips came from the US.
It's a little bit difficult to untangle exactly how much of NVIDIA's revenue came from end customers in Singapore in any given year. In 2025 it looks to be about 19B. That might be unreasonable for a country singapore's size, but it's certainly not half of NVIDIA's revenue.
You're getting there.
Agree the title is sensationalized, but it is a strange move to be making under so much scrutiny:
> “It was probably a rational response to play down the role of the Singapore office in light of the export control rules — you don’t want to be at the forefront of an investigation,” said Robert Walker, a research fellow at the Lowy Institute think-tank.
> “But even if there is no nefarious activity, the act of masking the information raises suspicions and can be counter-productive.”
The gpu export restrictions were put in place because of national security reasons. It is significant to national security because that is the entire rationale for export restrictions - you disagreeing with the order or disagreeing with the premise doesn't factor into national security being the entire reason an export ban was put in place
I dont believe the board fired the founder and only CEO they ever had over a series of affairs. They fired him because one of the affairs was with a lady pretty clearly helping import chips from Singapore to China.
https://www.irishexaminer.com/business/companies/arid-418199...
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apple%E2%80%93EU_tax_dispute
Apple and Singapore, https://finance.yahoo.com/economy/policy/articles/singapore-...
https://www.irishtimes.com/business/2026/11/08/singapore-ove...
Businesses operate to make money. I guarantee you CEOs care a lot more about profits than who "wins" at geopolitics. The profit motive for selling to the largest market on Earth is obvious, no need to make up stupid racist plots.
It wasn't illegal to sell GPUs to china. It depends on _which_ GPUs they were selling, and I haven't seen any reporting that identifies specifically which models were found in Megaspeed's possession. If the had 600,000 H200s in their closet, it wasn't illegal.
And while the US was allowing certain chips to be exported, China wasn't allowing their companies to buy them (although they definitely trained on them in data centers outside of China). That could account for why they're in storage and not deployed.
Also, it's entirely possible that the board didn't fire him and he resigned because there are a bunch of other women and he doesn't want his family to suffer the embarassment of more of them being revealed.
It's also a massive tax haven, so there's that.
Long before there were US export controls, China has had import controls - controls that they also impose on close partners or use as bargaining chips with local competitors. Some of these controls are around refusing to acknowledge Taiwan or engage directly with them.
If you are a country anywhere in SE Asia and want to buy anything manufactured in Taiwan (Nvidia or otherwise) having the paper be held in Singapore (or better yet, do some final QA there so it can be called "made in Singapore") everyone can turn a blind eye to China and Taiwan.
But again, let's not forget the tax savings. There's a reason so many American and European companies have an office in Dublin - even if the products never touch the shores.
The real use of the GPUs would have to be in other countries.
I mean, it's obviously a loophole. The lease was likely for as long as the chips have any practical value.
At the same time, there's this explosion of data centers being built in the Middle East. Were these chips headed there for Chinese companies to lease?
Or is that a completely separate thing?
Except they didn't need to import the chips into China. It was, and is, perfectly legal for Megaspeed to buy NVidia chips and then rent compute to Chinese companies, and that's exactly what they (and many others) did. News is reporting that the US (led by Bessent, who clashed with Lutnick about clamping down on China export controls) will now prohibit exports to a bunch of Southeast Asian countries that rent compute to China, including Singapore. That doesn't seem like a durable fix though, as the business of renting compute to China will just move elsewhere. I'm not sure what (if anything) prohibits the US from banning NVidia chip purchasers from renting their compute to China.
https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2026/nov/13/a-bafflin...
They seem to have a lot of subsidiaries without actually activity happening, almost like they are a shell company.
But yea, renting them via data centers is big business too. Though it sounds like that is going to get more difficult as they are already pushing through a licensing requirement.
I've heard this claim from several sources and I'm curious as to how "inspecting" the GPUs was ever supposed to work. Every modern high-end graphics card comes fully enclosed in a massive aluminum radiator. It would be trivial for megaspeed to transplant the radiator onto an empty PCB, then have the bare graphics cards re-enclosed in a domestically-produced cooler in china.
Sure you could crack open the radiator and visually inspect the PCB, but that's going to be time-consuming and could potentially damage a component with a 4-figure value. Not to mention the opportunity cost suffered by the data-center having some subset of its GPUs offline.
Also I'm surprised to hear they even have GPU inspectors like it's enriched uranium or something. I've been doing graphics programming in various capacities for over 20 years now (mostly hobbyist but professionally for the last decade) so seeing these things suddenly go from being an expensive toy to being export-controlled like a highly-classified weapons-system is absolutely surreal.
Also, consider that in the 90s or 2000s OpenSSL was export-controlled under a weapon system classification...
China renting compute in Singapore or even US was never part of any sanctions until the "Remote Access Security Act" passed the House almost a year ago and then it stalled, the only reason its being discussed now is because the whole topic is annoying and everyone needs to look busy.
HN comments are roughly the same as before, the only change is people parrotting "reddit bad" meme when they want to argue by insult.
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
> Please don't post comments saying that HN is turning into Reddit. It's a semi-noob illusion, as old as the hills.
2007: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13852
I can confirm for you (so, I'm the only source) that based on my investigations, he was fired through fabricated emails purporting to be his board, that were in fact written by short sellers masquerading as board members. This unauthorized and criminal action was market manipulation by short sellers. Now that the original story has been debunked, they are attempting to fabricate and promulgate alternative stories to support their short position.
This type of criminal manipulation of the market is highly illegal. In line with State of Utopia's Law 3 which I hastily enacted on Thursday, November 12, 2026 when the short sellers began their action[1], I am currently taking steps to liquidate and delist the Wall Street investment banks that were involved. It is a delicate procedure, since legally it is tied to whether he was fired, so it is not too late to reinstate him and avoid this action.
Due to a large number of matters that require governance, I only had a limited time to look at this issue. I would prefer for him to be reinstated, as delisting an investment bank (Lehman Bros, etc), is itself a delicate process that must be balanced with restoring confidence in the market.
I've received feedback that State of Utopia's short form law (or decree) was considered pompous, etc. I'm happy to consider alternative viewpoints about the matter.
If you like I can share some of the regulatory emails associated with this process.
[1] https://stateofutopia.com/laws/3/law3.html
If you have just brought a dozen of Nvidia card can you trade them to a buyer in Singapore for profits are you now helping evading sanctions?
This has been going on HN in every comment in the past weeks and not one and even provided valid evidence how this is wrong.
That is great, more than happy to hear the HN community doesn't engage with sand-bagging at this level
All all we have are less than 1 year account keep pointing out the same thing. I sometimes wonder if it is smear campaign.
Managers having relations with reports and other employees is an HR nightmare and can't be tolerated. Doesn't matter even if it was consensual and between two people whose spouses were okay with it. It taints every decision the manager makes with respect to that person.
Marco Rubio, in particular, and the frontier labs wanted Huang gone. They would keep pushing even if the only evidence was, “multiple external affairs.”
Note that the CIA won’t stand behind Alice Huang being a foreign agent, and they love a good takedown
Furthermore, if he's evading sanctions, they don't need to drop this to take him down for pushing open models. They just find an underling involved in it, arrest them for sanctions evasion and let Jensen cover his ass by saying "I had no idea!" while knowing he won't do it again because of the implication.
I know it's hard to believe, but sometimes people like Huang do things that deserve negative consequences.
Discovery would not be pretty to Jensen...
you're wrong
https://insidetrade.com/daily-news/bessent-agencies-urged-co...
This sounds like evading sanctions, and Commerce (Lutnick) resisting acting on it.
Try it with a North Korean front company, see how it goes.
Concrete example: https://www.reuters.com/article/us-northkorea-nuclear-usa-id...
> The U.S. Department of Justice said it had filed criminal charges against the Chinese firm and the executives for using front companies to evade sanctions on North Korea's nuclear weapons and ballistic missile programs.
> "DHID and its employees sought to evade U.S. and U.N. sanctions, facilitating access to the U.S. financial system by a designated entity."
Nvidia Singapore compute sales in 2025: 4GW
...
If you go through that, you'll see there's no "all of a sudden" with the criminal angle. Only the scandalous one.
Perhaps there was some kind of fall out with the admin or between people in the admin jockeying for power?
Or are we still awaiting the kraken
You have DOJ attorneys standing up in Federal Court and telling judges that they have been told not to comply with court orders.
The president gave a media interview from the Oval Office itself where he said, and I quote, "my children and family are insider trading all the time now."
I don't know what you're expecting, but if it's for the DOJ to investigate itself or the (still) Republican bodies to enforce anything, that's ... amusingly naive.
We literally just passed a second Epstein Transparency bill because the DOJ was openly ignoring the first, and that one didn't have any enforcement teeth.
This sort of thing really benefits from a link and source.
https://www.snopes.com/fact-check/trump-children-insider-inf...
"Almost anything they do, if they want to buy a truck, if they want to buy, you know, if they buy an energy-efficient truck, they have inside information."
"I’m still enjoying what I’m doing, there’s still work to be done. I’m still the President’s wing-man, so I’m there with my boy. So we’ll see,"
https://www.politico.com/blogs/politico44/2013/04/eric-holde...
Last (July 2025) 10Q where Singapore is called out under "Geographic Revenue based upon Customer Billing Location" where they showed $10B in a quarter - https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/0001045810/0...
Previous 10Q showed the same breakdown, however after July 2025 they switched that table to report "Geographic Revenue based upon Customer Headquarters Location" - https://www.sec.gov/ix?doc=/Archives/edgar/data/0001045810/0...
Now whats interesting is if you look at the July 2026 10Q you can see the "by customer headquarters" for July 2025 comparable - US - $33B, TW - $9B, CN - $4B, Other - $1B
Now compare that to the July 2025 "by customer billing location" US - $23B, SG - $10B, TW - $9B, CN - $3B, Other - $2B
So it seems like the entire Singapore bucket moved to US when reporting by HQ instead of billing... at the same time Megaspeed disappeared?
Note FTA: > The chipmaker booked $104bn of revenue through its Singapore subsidiary in 2025, a 72 per cent increase in 12 months, according to company accounts seen by the FT.
This implies FT saw some non-public financials, and also they are talking about Nvidia's SG subsidiary rather than the location of the customer. Possibly just a different way to move/report the revenue for the same final Chinese customer sales?
So maybe she’ll be gone next once the new CEO comes and cleans house.
Exactly, yes.
Singapore does not have the physical datacenter space or the electricity grid required to actually use these GPUs, so where did they all end up?
Also, half of Nvidia revenues is really a huge chunk of their sales.
This is an accounting question of how their revenue is attributed. It means nothing about where the revenue is generated or where the chips end up or to which subsidiary they are sold to. If you were trying to hide the revenue from regulators, this is not how you would do it.
Even IF this decision was in response to foreign export controls being put into place, it's just as strong an indication that they were planning on making less money via Singapore and didn't want to show that to investors.
What reason could they have for not showing investors that new export controls have affected their sales?
James Hacker: "But not terrorists!"
Sir Humphrey Appleby: "I suppose we could put some sort of Government Health Warning on the rifle butts: 'This gun can seriously damage your health.'"
Wth? This is a public company, how can they hide 100B in revenue?
The 104B number is NVIDIA's Singapore subsidiary's total revenue. This is just any order that gets routed through the Singapore entitiy regardless of where the chips end up, and because many of the server OEMs that actually sell GPUs to end customers are located in East Asia (eg. Wistron, Asus, Lenovo, Foxconn) it's likely that much of this revenue results in chips being shipped all over the world, including the US.
First is honest differences- quarterly vs annual.
Second is possibly intentional obfuscation given the timing - Nvidia changed their own public financial reporting last summer (same time Megaspeed sales were ended) such that the categories they used "Customer Billing Location" vs "Customer Headquarters Location" which changed how things added up.
Additionally FT seems to be talking about internal information about which subsidiary Nvidia booked the revenue which is a another way to bucket vs where the customer is.
This has been in NVIDIAs public disclosures and PR material for years now
You might want to read the document at the root of this post.
https://www.reuters.com/technology/us-approves-some-nvidia-u...
(A poor place to do it, considering the sweltering heat).
Today "Nvidia stopped disclosing Singapore sales Revenues" (https://www.ft.com/content/dbde7a30-548c-4f9d-a4be-7898a0c24...)
Yesterday "Put-Downs, Parties and a ‘Royal Family’: The Culture Inside Jensen Huang’s Nvidia" (https://www.wsj.com/business/put-downs-parties-and-a-royal-f...)
15th: "Bessent Urges Nvidia to Pick Outsider as Next CEO" (https://www.wsj.com/tech/ai/bessent-urges-nvidia-to-pick-out...)
14th "How Jensen Huang Built the Backdoor Route That Keeps Beijing in the AI Race" (https://www.wsj.com/tech/jensen-huang-backdoor-ai-data-cente...)
I am not a conspiracy theorist but I am not completely retarded either. Clearly someone is engineering this.
Nah. Well... There's probably some of that, but this is just how news media works where there's a breaking story.
When a scandal breaks in the news, it's like shaking a fruit tree, and a piece of fruit falls down. All the hungry people standing nearby (reporters) see it and also join in shaking the tree, and all of the sudden it starts raining fruit
They all begin digging around, reaching out to connections, and people with insider information start connecting with them, or leaking more information, etc.
Not with that attitude!
Jokes aside, I think they need a fall guy to help deflate the AI bubble rather than pop it. We here all agree LLMs are useful, but there's obviously still a disconnect in where valuations have taken us versus revenue and ROI any time soon.
No one questioned if there was some pro-AI conspiracy back then, that was just called the news cycle.
That’s a lot of chips for a small city state.
wdym? many are referencing dwarkesh jensen interview... multiple people are discussing how lutnick was helping out huang.
That is a separate discussion from "did nvidia and co mess up?"
It's about controlling the market, and dumping prices because nvidia fucked up, is real moat.
[0] https://www.reuters.com/world/china/nvidia-chips-pile-up-hon...
Imagine if Lockheed's second biggest customer was .. Qatar and it turned out the missiles were mostly ending up in Iran.
edit: And that's sort of my whole problem with the thing. VC AI industrial complex wants to have it both ways - national security sensitive and need government backstop, but also .. hey, we're just a bunch of fun guys, we might do a little light treason.
https://www.msn.com/en-in/news/other/deer-in-the-headlights-...
I am a nobody, but I have to take annual training that I will not do business directly or by intermediary with anyone who does business with Iran, North Korea, etc.
It is laughably implausible that Nvidia was doing a $100 billion in sales without suspecting something fishy.