> theres some sort of strategy of tension regarding cyber/fraility of systems being pushed.
> 'Manufacturing Consent', new Congress AI regulation for industry capture in the pipeline
both capture my inclinations, but the other thing is this can simply be symptoms/indicators.
looking at the recent faa thing, this could be "move fast and break things" happening in real time.
new contractors, new programs, more outsourcing/privatizations etc,
palantir type companies moving into new places.
this is right after midterms, so the admin is doing its final phase of plays
I wonder (and have no idea) whether the increased reports of services being down is a case of the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, or a actual increase in failure rate.
If I was asked to armchair-pattern-match, I'd say that there's a combination of two things: (a) a wider fear-based environment where rapid modernization is being pushed heavily, and (b) an increase in tools that give false confidence on change management.
AI is tuned to speak confidently and ship independently; it is rare that it will suggest that one go back to a broad survey of stakeholders to ensure no Chesterton's Fence is being torn down (https://fs.blog/chestertons-fence/). "I've read the documentation and logs, and nothing suggests this system needs these legacy capabilities/components/capacity" is something we hear all day, and it is a siren's song if there ever was one.
Couple that with a general (and valid!) consensus that modernization of legacy systems must be accelerated for a variety of reasons - to mitigate this new and continuing "Black October" of hyper-agile agent-driven cyberattacks (whether the network is public or private); to have more flexible infrastructure for new features to stay ahead; to allow human teams to show their efficacy in a world where technology jobs are increasingly at risk - and you have a perfect storm where change management is no longer what it once was.
10 years ago, most work happened in Word or Excel on a desktop app on your computer, so you weren’t depending on a constellation of cloud based SaaS vendors. If outlook went down for an hour, you’d just continue working without the disruption of an inbox. Now, the path to do your work requires online vendors to be online, so if they go down you’re blocked.
I don't necessarily agree about the warnings. AI often gives me "now be careful" warnings about it's output along with the caveat at the bottom of each ChatGpt page.
I suspect the situation is that AI's caveats are just easier to ignore than a person's warnings. Plus all the other factors you list. Also, AI tends to give a person the kind of communication they ask for. I always ask for options but I suspect other people ask for just answer and so they get them.
I think he's just pointing out that AI has made news of IT failures "more interesting" and thus, more reports are getting out where in the past, they'd not be interesting.
The OP is giving an alternate explanation of the general phenomena that this headline is a part of. Nothing wrong with describing the framework that software "drift" is happening in.
Which is to say, a parent post here on HN doesn't narrow the topic to it's focus. That's what makes discussion here interesting.
That's my impression; a total of zero of the popular recent ones have been related to "AI" or Cyber attacks, but every comment in every thread, talks about those two as if they were the underlying cause.
The FAA's recent outage for example, at its core, seems like people trying to rush needed upgrades that were slow for a specific reason (e.g. reducing the testing window for 90 to 30-days).
The Microsoft outage seems like three different things linked together (and poor "full failure" recovery prep, lengthening the outage).
The bank "outage" may not have even existed, 2/3 of the banks claimed they didn't have an outage at all, and the other said it was a limited technical issue. The articles were based on DownDetector spikes.
You need to be more skeptical of what organizations say when they have a lot to lose. Nobody takes responsibility for situations unless there's way to offload some or all of the blame. They have every incentive to lie about the situation to make it go away. Politics often plays the biggest role in these situations.
Those things are usually integrated as some type of TPP and are not directly related to any core banking services: If Zelle connections fails, usually nothing gets broken in your "real" account data, since Zelle is connected by whatever API stack to the bank
It takes two to tango.
If $BANK_A has a problem transferring to $BANK_B does that necessarily mean both banks are experiencing an outage? Surely the common user (and therefore Downdetector) are likely to report a false-positive...
Are you some sort of psychic? While Microsoft has shared portions of its internal review with some journalists, and are supposedly planning on releasing it publicly next week, in the FAA, banks, and NSA cases we have very little information aside from non-technical statements from the affected with clear reasons not to immediately divulge verifiable details as their investigations get under way.
You're out here categorically saying none of these had an AI or cyber-attack angle with no verifiable proof and having a tantrum that other people are doing the same thing in reverse.
The list of unanswered questions is long. Maybe focus on pushing for more details instead of immediately saying "nothing to see here" regarding a series of important failures within a week's time.
BTW here's JPMorganChase's statement:
> JPMorganChase has experienced a temporary issue related to a software bug in on-premise hardware systems – there is no evidence this is cyber-related. Where we were party to a transaction involving other banks, those banks may have been impacted, but this is not a systemic issue. Customers still have access to their accounts and funds.
If you were trying to send your rent payment via Zelle from your Citibank account to your landlord's Chase account and it continually failed yesterday with no clear reason immediately provided, of course any complaint is a "witch hunt" since your Citibank account "works."
There is a near 100% chance they are sharing an interpretation that is more friendly to themselves than the facts, but a near 0 chance they are lying. A major outage at a large company or government department will have hundreds of people, at minimum, involved in the response. If the company lies about it, somebody will talk to the press. They know this, so they will not lie.
> You need to be more skeptical of what organizations say when they have a lot to lose.
So let me see if I understand what I should be:
- Be more skeptical of official explanations, including where it includes a technical breakdown of how it occurred (e.g. Microsoft/Outlook outage).
- Be less skeptical of random commenters claiming, without proof, that it is AI or Cyber Attacks.
Because that's the implied point you're making. Be more skeptical of A and less skeptical of B, even though A has someone placing their reputation behind it, and B is anonymous commenters throwing made up theories out into the ether.
> The FAA's recent outage for example, at its core, seems like people trying to rush needed upgrades that were slow for a specific reason (e.g. reducing the testing window for 90 to 30-days).
The explanation for this one still doesn't ring true for me and that's exacerbated by how many times the story has changed after telling the public that they didn't need to know the reasons.
Agree, though, that the rest do have reasonable explanations
IDK what the current explanation is but I remember even in the early 20 teens FAA workers were ringing alarms that the entire control system was critically out of date and in need of upgrades and repairs. That they were having issues sourcing reliable FLOPPY disks, which they STILL use in 2026. This of course went almost completely ignored.
Given how many companies seem to be working hard to have all programming work done by AI, and pushing out everyone who says this sounds like a bad idea, is "AI" really not going to be a significant part of "rushing out needed updates"?
Is "Claude says it looks good so let's skip the usual testing window and push to prod on a Friday" really not a sentence you can imagine being said in this current environment?
I am talking about outages that have already recently occurred. You're making a distinct point about a hypothetical.
My point is that people are taking a potential future problem and applying to actual things that have recently happened, that didn't fit that mold. Which is incorrect.
When AI or Cyber Attacks cause an outage, people are absolutely right to say so. But claiming - without proof, that every outage is related to the two is noise.
In my line of work I deal with a lot of banks. They have been absolutely panicked for the last few months as they have been using AI to find and exploit bugs in their own software (A huge number of banks are members of project glasswing and other AI cyber testing with less limits than the public ones we get). This has forced them to drop almost everything else and immediately address updates in their systems, especially to a lot of legacy software that's sat around forever.
Just this many updates is going to cause instability in itself. Old systems that aren't touched can run forever without many problems, but when you can RCE said app the normal 3+ months of testing goes out the window. Now imagine this with tons of bugs in hundreds or thousands of applications at a single bank and you can see why things are starting to get unstable.
Did you see down detector today? Apple, Google, Meta and others that usually never show up were featured. The JDK RCE is also a massive zero-day. I can’t make it through the Google auth flow on my desktop. It’s not a normal day.
This situtation reminds me of the East Palestine train derailment in Ohio. A bad train accident caused a big chemical spill, made national news. For months afterward, any issue with any train in the state was reported as news. People thought the trains were breaking down. In reality, train derailments happen pretty often but it's not usually a big deal so nobody hears about it.
Yeah, I think it's not just the Frequency Illusion, but also the fact that news outlets jump on whatever topic is "hot" at the moment. On the cynical side, it's pretty established that outrage drives engagement, so the they have incentive to pour fuel on that fire and rile people up. It does make it hard to get an objective sense of the actual severity of things. Dang yellow journalism! :::thumps hand on table:::
100%. Everything is rage-bait nowadays. And AI is the newest toy they can use. Every time we've had something go down in the past ~6months, "AI did it" was all over the comments.
It's worth scrutiny - I think. Microsoft said they write 30% of their code with AI in mid 2025. They had a major outage.
Naturally, when you tell an entire occupation that they are no longer necessary employees and that AI writes all your code, when something breaks in a major way those people are probably going to ask the question.
This kind of thing happened in clusters well before AI was around too. In 2015 we had planes grounded due to a router issue and the New York Stock Exchange halted for 4 hours. When the Wall Street Journal web page went down people went nuts about being attacked as well [1].
Summer of 2019 was also a pretty good one [2].
I fully expect AI will cause insane disruptions at some point, but all evidence points to this just being a series of normal outages. Worst timing ever to have a patch Tuesday.
Yes, I don't personally believe that the recent outages stem from AI usage in a codebase, and I'm also highly doubtful that the NSA + Microsoft are just shipping slop straight to production.
As a developer, I know very well that systems break, sometimes frequently (AI or not). It has always been the case, and likely always will be the case.
But, I am not surprised that people are mentioning AI - feels like most posts on here for the last year have involved AI in some capacity.
Is it possible that the false of productivity is leading to worse products and massive loss in valuable headcount? Instead of AIs directly writing bad buggy code? Or is "everything rage-bait, and AI is all sunshine"
I believe it's also possible that a large portion of the world wants this to be true more than it actually is so attribution to things that have nothing to do with AI go directly to AI as a knee-jerk reaction.
If we're also just vibing it (like the majority of code these days) then I vibe that there are a lot of AI-apologists that desperately don't want their magic machine to be cast in a negative light, lest their easy i-win button gets taken away or devalued.
I think both sides are exhausted by too many people on the other side have a non-nuanced argument. I fall in the middle. I love making stuff with AI, it's fun. It's become a better search engine for me and helped with many other things in my life. But it'd be really naive to not see the enormous downsides. They're everywhere and not pleasant.
There's a group of people who think AI is perfect and will solve all of humanity's problems. That's annoying. There's another group of people who think AI is the worst thing to ever happen to humanity and is the downfall of society. These people are more vocal in my experience and they're everywhere. If you ever use AI you're a bad person who they'll disown like you're racist. It's somehow become the most popular 'social justice' issue of our time even as ICE exists alongside it. These people see a problem and immediately try to figure out how AI is involved. That's far more annoying.
Best example I can give that came up in my circle recently is the video game "Big Walk". It was recently denied for a silly award nomination because the awards have a strict no-AI policy. Which to me is absolutely fine, go nuts. But the vitriol towards this game, that everybody absolutely ADORED before the developer disclosed that they fixed ~10 lines (!) of code with AI because they couldn't figure it out otherwise, is absolutely bonkers. People I respect treated it like they were mourning something that WAS great until this catastrophe happened.
AI is based on massive theft. The reason it can fix those 10 little lines! is due to massive theft and skirting the law(Aaron Schwarts was surveilled for years by the FBI for downloading scientific articles that he legally had access to, when an AI company steals them nobody bats an eye). Also AI and our industry has enabled ICE and state repression programs. Think Flock, Palantir's ImmigrationOS, Israel's "daddy's home" bombing program. Regular people see what our industry is enabling and feel disgusted. and people in our industry(and on hackernews) enable these atrocities by getting those large amounts of $$$.
These kinds of things happened before AI. It's not clear whether the incidence has increased since AI, or maybe AI is leading to faster development and therefore higher rates of incidents may be due to shipping more code, faster, while perhaps maintaining a similar or better level of incident to code/progress ratio. Or, there could just be more attention as GP suggests. Pointing to one example of a company that's using AI and has has a major incident doesn't really tell us much, especially when most companies who haven't had major incidents are probably using AI in similar amounts.
It would be interesting if someone could do a proper analysis, though!
I would assume if anything it is that the open weight models are lagging by 6-8 months and 6 months ago Mythos was announced.
It would hardly be shocking that hostile nations are able to cause some problems with Mythos level tools.
If anything, it is more interesting how we can invade another country and the idea that the country or a collection of hostile countries could hit us back in any way, shape or form is just an impossibility. An insane conspiracy theory.
Maybe it is not that but surely the probablity is not zero.
Mine says "we're a month or two overdue for major infrastructure outages", because my gut is absolutely scared of the cyber capabilities of the current models (including the open weight ones).
Frankly, for the past few days, my gut is pushing a hypothesis to explain why nothing happened yet: bad actors are holding off until the winter starts.
It's nowhere near the kind of readiness and preparedness campaigns of the cold-war of course, but it's a step up in alertness that's higher than anything I can remember.
I don't think the two are comparable. The 2022 resilience framework led to the publication of the gov.uk/prepare website in 2024, but it had no paid reach and was quickly forgotten. And Preparing for Emergencies was launched in response to a perceived terrorist threat post-9/11 and Madrid train bombings. So you might take this as an indication that the UK government believes there is something to be concerned about.
My gut is screaming that everything is mostly normal, but the kids aren't alright.
Too many people are addicted to their smartphones and don't feel the same level of pride they used to in their work. All systems are shared, instead of one person being the ruler of a certain part of the stack, it's a revolving door and it's rare that anyone stays somewhere for even 5-10yrs. It leaves a wake of modifications that nobody else can keep up with. Also, the tech industry is moving fast just to move fast, a lot of old infra is still C++ and COBOL but good luck hiring anyone to use that, so they have to convert the systems to use the Latest Tech of the Day. The old, stable people don't have any interest in learning the new thing, and would rather retire with their knowledge. The new people want to rebuild from scratch in the New Thing and are convinced they need to job hop immediately after.
I’ve only stayed at a single job for more than 2 years in my entire 20+ year career (about 6 years there). Companies never give significant raises or do anything to motivate us to stay, so when I can switch jobs and give myself a raise, I do. The company I actually stayed with was going through an IPO and the stock price kept going up for the years following, so that made me stay. It’s a job. They pay me, I work. Why should I have any loyalty? They fired me after those 6 years too on a whim during a layoff. I see no point in having pride.
My gut is not a good source on this, so I will use my brain instead. There were 2 major outages that happened in quick succession. The MSFT outage and the FAA. It is unusual for two major outages to occur so close together, but that is not enough to conclude that they are somehow related and not a coincidence.
There are now post mortems for both outages. The FAA outage was caused by a botched upgrade to an ancient system. The MSFT outage was caused by a latent concurrency bug that was surfaced by a later incident. My experience in this industry tells me that this is plausible because these are exactly the type of things that tend to cause outages. My industry experience also tells me that hundreds to thousands of people were involved in the responses to these incidents, so if the companies were lying about the cause it would be leaked to the press and posted about all over Blind.
The other outages all seem to be normal nothing burger outages that happen all the time and nobody ever hears about because they don't make the news or even the front page of HN. The reason they make the news now is most likely because we just had the MSFT / FAA outages and that's in the news cycle now, not because they are somehow linked.
I can put my finger on it, and nothing sinister is afoot.
Most of the rest of them I can wave off as probably incompetence and maybe augmented by LLM-psychosis in decision-makers, and the general level of chaos in IT these days. The NSA internal network being down is pretty suspicious. Maybe the Trump administration rot has just spread that far, but that is making me think there could be actual cyberwarfare going on.
[To be clear: I mean exactly what I said, which is "there could be" which is not the same as "I think there is" -- so call it a 5%-10% chance of real cyberwarfare -- which means I'm not dismissing those claims out of hand, and find the claims at least plausible, even if I don't currently believe them]
Interesting thought but who are the combatants and why are they engaging now? Corporation? Nation states? Rogue ai? We have no news of significant consequences from the outages thus far other than inconvenienced travelers. Quite benign form of warfare thus far.
My personal barometer: when do government insiders sell all of their stock? They have already done all of the insider trading. Fleeing the sinking ship the second they hear of Bad News would be in line with previous behavior.
Yeah, agreed. I look at patterns. When there are long term outages across multiple disciplines, something systemic is being changed for good or ill. In this case, it being right around the midterms, I'm thinking its ill. Organizations (not sure which, Peter Thiel?) are trying to push us into a total surveillance system, I'm thinking some of these things are related to that.
Yeah "cyber thing went down" has certainly become a reporting trend. I'm not sure we would have even heard about NSA internal network issues a year ago. May or may not be significant.
Though at the same time, the public isn't privy to even 10% of the incidents going on right now.
The information I have is consistent with general cybercrime and script kiddie patterns, just a much higher volume, and much larger diversity of targets.
I think it lies at the intersection of Occam's and Hanlon's razors. The simplest explanation is incompetence brought on by a lack of skill from cuts, and therefore stupidity not malice.
It's probably both stupidity and malice, especially on the government side. Project 2025 makes sure that malice is there as a starting point and then the current loyalty-driven hiring practices means that stupidity is a key factor in the execution.
> The frequency illusion, also known as the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, is a cognitive bias in which a person notices a specific concept, word, or product more frequently after recently becoming aware of it.
In the case of government, we have an administration that works on whims and guesses, and moves too fast, breaking a lot of things. We have absolutely seen more human-caused-issues.
Must be a little bit of both right? Like FAA grounding + Microsoft outage are both notable on their own, but the subsequent things would usually be background noise IMO.
I also think generally that AI is probably both the cause and solution to these problems. We're certainly getting more code churn than otherwise, and in lots of cases that's really good! But you're going to have to deal with inevitable instability too.
Aside: I forget the name of the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon when it hasn't been discussed in awhile. When I'm reminded of it I begin seeing it happening frequently for the next few days. I wish I was joking. I assume it's the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon phenomenon.
I've heard the term "frecency bias" a portmanteau of frequency and recency to refer to people focusing intently on a set of outlier events that happen to occur with a heightened frequency very recently.
I'm sure most of us here have been on the receiving end of managers suddenly obsessed with a failure mode because it happened to occur twice in one month.
It must be more than just that because it's not just the experience of one person noticing things. It probably starts that way, but then the stories get shared and they bubble up more often. So it's another phenomenon on top of it.
(This of course is on top of whatever unusual things might actually be happening)
It's the same as when Boeing had failure then we heard only of Boeing and other failures for few weeks.
It's not just the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon but because of the previous failures news are interested more to report on failures. Like when did we normally care that NSA had an outage?
I think the real ones were the Microsoft and FAA due to deploying the AI slop.
The other ones seem to be usual outages that normally no one reports on.
Technically, the "Baader–Meinhof phenomenon" is people personally noticing X once it's been reported. What you are describing is technically a "news wave" or "Media Feeding Frenzy".
But I'd note, these "named after a thing" phenomena (eponnyms) are kind of terrible for exact description since their definition tends to be fuzzy, there's a temptation to fudge their borders and they create an insider jargon (if only I could a device that could reach of the computer and slap everyone who says "steelman" when they mean strengthen an argument, etc).
Someone this morning told me there might be a 3 month blackout in the US, somehow connected to other recent technological failures. I later learned the blackout theory is based on a The Simpsons episode, and even there it was a much shorter time period but has been exaggerated.
So certainly there is a big social-psychological phenomenon. Or it's gonna be a cold winter! :)
With the trilateral summit scheduled for Thursday it's possible some showing off is going on between the three letter agencies in the three countries... after all they can be first movers on vulns that are likely to be patched soon
I may not understand expectations, or the law around this, but I find it a little surprising that the NSA would publicly announce that their internal and highly classified network is down. At least not before getting it back up, running and secure again.
In a spy movie world, someone deep in enemy territory would be relieved to see the Reuters headline, after failing to reach the NSA network and having no other channel to ask (picking up the phone to call the US embassy would get your door busted by the local men in black).
I imagine, for the paranoid spy, not being able to call home could also mean "the enemy has severed our comms, we've been compromised, burn everything and run!".
That sort of communication is necessary for sure, but I'd imagine int he world of espionage some sort of coded false news report would be more likely, eg 'batboy found after 5 hour panic search.'
Of course, it might be a limited hangout to soften the blow of actually being compromised.
He is saying that in the spy world due to over classification people end up living in their own little different realities and what the commenter above says happens in some of them. Hence the many-worlds.
The initial news reports were not from officials but "people familiar with the matter". Practically speaking, once the story is already circulating, officials have the decision between:
1. say nothing in an official capacity and let people speculate
2. make an official announcement to head-off any concerns and speculation
War drives profits. Why isn't the insanely unpopular Iran war ending? Money. All of these "outages" can be blamed on Russia, Iran, etc when the time is right.
Anybody that doesn't understand there is a classified plan to internally destabilize whether through legitimate exploits or planned accidents is woefully unaware of the history of the DoD and CIA.
You're being downvoted but I think people need to take some time and become a little more familiar with the history of who's in charge of these institutions, and the things they've been willing to do in the past.
Its either that systems are starting to decay because everyone is rapidly offshoring all the hard parts of their jobs to mediocre chat bots..
Or they're actually trying to cause some sort of public stress about the frailty of systems.. They dont go around publishing that their critical systems are going down. It is odd.
Law wise, every bit of classified information has to be justified as damaging to national security if publicly released in order to be classified. Most non-critical classified networks can't justify classification for the status.
I find it more likely that NSANet status is not classified than I do that 5 people committed a felony to tell CNN this information...
It's probably not down, probably some honeypot announcement with some other agenda. Like announcing to the neighbourhood you're going off on holiday then staying next door to see who comes up to the property to investigate while 'you're gone'.
I feel like something started after Elon purchased twitter and made all those personnel deep cuts. In the era prior, it wasn't too hard to look around and see people who were dragging productivity down. Their cuts would be an improvement. Twitter into X looked to cut to the bone and despite a few hiccups, nothing catastrophic happened to the service layer. This ushered in a new era of tech department downsizing that feels like it is still happening today. Ask any new graduate how the job search if going. Sprinkle in a little DOGE + time and we are starting to see the exhausted people supporting these glued together systems experience real large scale failures.
Yeah, you can do fine with only one set of eyes on a problem. Yeah, it is more "efficient" in the short term. Culling lots of do-nothing people in your organization isn't going to produce many tears. Even so, devs and IT departments are now missing all sorts of backup and vital personnel that keep the gears oiled and running.
Or maybe it’s the enshitification from the AI slop movement. People who don’t understand the ramifications of their PRs making giant frequent changes to codebases while maintainers feel pressure to hit the approve button.
Let's not judge people submitting AI slop PRs too harshly. Maybe AI slop against open-source codebases, but a lot of the proprietary AI slop is a result of management directives and organizational pressures, not engineer desire to merge in crap code.
This is doubly true at this time of year, when we're likely to see people pushing to get work delivered by the end of December so that they can include it in yearly reviews. I'll happily merge PRs I don't understand if that's what keeps my job.
> Maybe AI slop against open-source codebases, but a lot of the proprietary AI slop is a result of management directives and organizational pressures, not engineer desire to merge in crap code.
Then it is a failure of software dev individualism. There is a long-proven, battle-tested solution to management making unreasonable demands from labor: Unionization.
That is the point of the post. It started with something very public and non-critical and has slowly made its way through the full pipeline into real systems our infrastructure relies upon. The consequences are finally showing. It is too bad most of the people who were raising the red flags were sacrificed to layoffs & dismissals.
Sometimes the industries were the stakes are lower overcompensate and end up having tremendous quality and work ethic, in video game design for example crunch and 70 hour workweeks are a thing, while established physicians can do with 10-20 hours.
People seem to be leaning on the AI speculation from the "vibe coded" angle, but couldn't this also be an "AI is the reason" from the attacker side? I think we've seen more than a fair share of AI assisted exploits that chain many small vulnerabilities into something more pronounced. I'm thinking of the rash of attacks in SK and China against Banks using offensive harnesses.
I'd be more willing to believe the network in question here was under an attack load that either was probed or exploited far enough that shutting it down was worthwhile. It seems more reasonable to me than believing they've let AI run amok on their internals such that it's now failing.
Not because I'm deifying the NSA but because the system has to be decades old, at least, and I wouldn't expect significant changes to something that "just works".
If they were attacked, they wouldnt be calling the WSJ and screaming about it. We're being fkd with, theres some sort of strategy of tension regarding cyber/fraility of systems being pushed.
Couldn’t agree more. The cacophony of significant events happening across the globe at any given moment is impossible to distill. National news is not a good-faith sampling of that pool, but rather a mindful selection. Pre-programming is real and frequent.
Not to defend the cut or weigh into politics, but how much of 18F was specifically security related? Because that's what's required here, rather than tech generalists.
I cannot comment on the specifics, they change with time. I had few interaction with technologists in one of the federal government body almost a decade ago. Those people were thoughtful, expert with first primitives and open to what you are doing as long as the intent is met.
Compare to that, most people in industry at this point are either business disguised as technologist or in some cases experts in one vertical.
In government security is political. And what we had with 18F was the beginning of a government office that was both tech savvy and politically savvy.
Who decides when a DDOS of Trumpcare.gov that is traced back to Akamai servers was an attempt to extort government contracts or “those pesky Chinese state actors”?
Lots of strong opinions on 18F's closure. Here is the GSA Inspector General's October 2024 assessment, done during Biden, and prior to Trump/DOGE actions.
Unless it has recently changed, all the smart people go to private industry, NSA employees are capped because of government payscales. You want highly skilled people? Fucking pay them.
Well, when you put it that way, it’s amazing how much just a drop in the bucket is able to accomplish. We should fill all of our buckets with at least a drop.
Yeah, the assumption that 18F would have prevented this is ... absurd. The problems we're facing are ai related, and external entities are more capabile, nimble, and motivated than our beloved government (right now anyway).
I believe that even less than I believe the pardons won't be issued. The world has expected a lot of things from the US, only to see the exact opposite happen in last years.
I wouldn't be surprised if Trump pardoned his corrupt friends, as many US presidents have done before. But I also wouldn't be surprised if he went a step further and issued preemptive pardons to all his loyal servants who so cheerfully supported him throughout his circus show.
That would mean nobody would face any personal responsibility for the damage they've caused. The main reason this hasn't been done on such a massive scale before is the political backlash. And Trump simply doesn't give a damn about that.
We need a court finding that says preemptive pardons are not what the Constitution allows. It makes no sense for even the President to offer a get-out-of-jail card with no expiration date.
Guess who screams I’m competent the loudest? The incompetent workers.
On a serious note, I see it as a paradox. Competency is built through struggles, and the non-competent do not want someone that seemed lesser at some point to outrank them, be the go to person.
But, perhaps, you could hire juniors or grads who like, have education in a relevant field, instead of someone who does not and goes by a moniker like "Big Balls"?
I think the opportunity right now where we have powerful AI hacking systems but not enough protections is to establish long-term presence in all networks of interest. Not bring them down.
Completely agree. Things are moving too fast and so are breaking.
For example, we updated a GCP managed base image of Ubuntu that was released with 350 CVEs patched, some were as high as 9.8. In doing so, they (GCP) changed the DEFAULT setting for hardware GRO from off by default to on. That's a massive networking change packed into a security update.
We only caught it AFTER it started causing issues in production. We didn't have the OS pinned because (decently valid reasons) or catch it in non-prod (decent reason + human mistake).
This is on a modern highly automated tested resilient well architected platform.
I can only imagine these other platforms are dramatically more exposed that we are, hence these common large scale outages.
That assumes that people did not already have long-term presence in networks of interest.
More plausible to me is that spy agencies had previously found and used some of these hundreds or thousands of vulnerabilities to hack into those networks just fine. But now other people like cyber criminals are using these vulnerabilities via AI. That is messing up both the attackers who had already gotten in quietly and do not want the attention and the defenders who now have to respond to a noisy intrusion they cannot ignore.
Also, anyone anywhere that horded/designed exploits will be wanting to use their backlog of these "assets" before systems are patched. From criminal networks to nation states.
Outages could be grey-hat testers and emergency updates.
A temporary period like we are experiencing is to be expected when moving to a time where a single engineer can perform the equivalent work of a team of excellent engineers working for weeks. Security has always been a game of who has the capabilities, means, and requirement for any given attack surface.
It reminds me of the aftermath of the DCA crash in 2025. For a few weeks it felt like planes were falling out of the sky as a bunch of (sadly somewhat commonplace) non-airliner crashes got national attention they otherwise wouldn't have.
Elon Musk and Trump with DOGE. They cut ~300k federal workers, cut governments contracts across all departments, including the FAA, NSA, home land security... those organizations have been raising alarms since that the cuts to civilian contractors etc would lead to outages and issues since, including pentagon, DoD, etc. But you know Idiocracy.
Bloated government agencies want to justify infinitely more tax dollars, that doesn’t mean we should treat them as unbiased actors nor the people who want to blame making changes to the government for every problem. People have to be able to elect representatives who make changes to government agencies without being treated like doing so is evil and stupid.
Very much agree with you that there is a pattern emerging. I think I agree with your conclusion as well.
There are a couple of things to keep in mind with nsanet though:
- It can handle anywhere between confidential to TS//SCI information
- It is largely (completely?) an off-infra network, meaning that it doesn't run over the same infrastructure that the open internet uses. It uses an entirely(?) discrete backbone. SIPRNET uses similar architecture.
- You cannot easily cross pollinate data from unclassified networks to nsanet. Everything from removable media to EMSEC is considered prohibited without proper channels being informed and paperwork being performed.
- Lastly, we're unaware of the timing of this supposed source. This could have been over the last week or a month ago or <n>. Scant detail is given, so I'm unwilling to believe "lolz nsa pwnd" just yet.
Beyond that it's also typically blocked by GPO prohibiting USB, so even if that were the case, the net result would be no real data transfer and a nice email to the DA mailgroup about the workstation and logged in user who triggered the alert.
I remember the cork board outside the dfac with phones and ipods screwed through the screen to the board... all the ones folks plugged into the sipr for one reason or another.
Stuxnet was preloaded thumb drives that were scattered in areas where people plugged them in on accident. Either you don't understand the DTA controls and processes, or the people around you were committing federal offenses and were being tracked.
Unspecified computer parts were interdicted by US intelligence while being shipped to Neda Industrial and infected with Stuxnet. Four other external vendors working on the enrichment plant were also compromised, likely by Israeli intelligence physically entering buildings.
Stuxnet then spread across each companies internal networks and onto USB drives that were then carried into the facility and plugged into the air gapped network.
It occurs to me that even if the recent outages are mostly just growing pains from rapid/careless AI adoption, a sufficiently advanced AI cyberattack would be designed to be indistinguishable from normal outages.
They are so far, but I would expect the same kind of public do-not-fear response if this was a coordinated cyber attack and the US is at war with an adversary that has experienced the power and consequence of targeted cyber capabilities. If they didn't pursue their own program in earnest after StuxNet I would be shocked.
We collectively are very much in arm-chair speculation at this point. If this is a coordinated cyber attack the US government right now wouldn't want to demonstrate weakness or fault. Iran would be the obvious culprit... but going full arm-chair on speculation... There was a major and disappointing result in our elections to the current powers that be...
If this was a staged set of attacks carefully done to minimize casualties... I bet it would be enough to declare a state of emergency and get additional executive powers "legitimately". If that was the case I would expect more propaganda and less bury it under the rug if that was going on.
Be careful out there the world is scary. Don't take any of this as fact, this is all personal speculation based on my own observations. Let me stand-up from my armchair and go for a walk...
Absolutely agree. All of those are practical and viable threat actors.
Based on my personal experience and to a certain extent sitting back down in my arm chair. I don't believe this is either China or Russia, they both have priorities that don't immediately involve the US and (as a government) the US is actively supporting both right now in very desirable (to them) ways.
Internal US action and Iran both seem equally likely in my head right now, but this is purely speculation and attribution is the hardest part to actually nail down when a state actor is involved.
This and the continued outages, such as the new Apple services outage, all collectively feel to close together without some evidence of a shared infrastructure causing it or a coordinated attack.
I don't personally believe this is "AI agents hacking the planet". The companies involved (well at least half of the outages I've seen) have enough compliance and protection obligations they are regularly audited against that my Occam's Razor gut feeling tells me that this is either long established persistent and maintained access being detonated one-by-one OR its a focused attack by one or more teams under the same directive taking down significant US focused institutions for attack or reprisal.
I would include in this list all of South America both government actors, disgruntled private citizens who feel they are beyond the reach of US authorities, and paramilitary or drug cartels.
The only problem with that bias is it only takes into account the hyper sensitivity and press these events are getting.
While all flights grounded is significant on it's own, and would have got press, even in a world where the fear of AI or foreign interference wasn't so strong, but there's been more than a few substantial local and regional groundings due to software over the past 4-5 years.
Microsoft outage is not new, Teams and Outlook have had more than a handful of outages way before the current doomer craze. While I had to search these for accurate recall, having worked closely with Microsoft for a decade plus, the recent outage is not isolated and to jump to conclusions is short sighted. For example, pre-doomsday summary of Microsoft's noteworthy outages: (1) Azure Outage -Sep 2018 South Central US (San Antonio DC); (2) Recurring multi-day Teams outage that effected users world wide February - April 2020 (3-4 outages in total); (3) December 2021 - Azure Active Directory outage locked people out of Azure and Outlook for several hours. (4) July 2022 - half-day outage for exchange, teams, sharepoint for most users. Same span outlook and exchange were down much like this last event for several hours. (5) Jan & Feb 2023 several outages for globoal Microsoft Outlook and network events.
That's not even all of the events in the last 5-6 years.
Optimizely, NSA network, and FAA mostly would have been under reported and or ignored by the general public.
I'm not saying this time couldn't be different this time, but what is the thesis? AI, foreign actors, incompetence?
"I don't know what, but something is clearly happening" is fear talking not rational thinking. Not all dots require connections. If you had full awareness of all the wild things that go on in one day, the amount of correlation you could draw from that if you're trying to tell a story would be pretty salacious.
Why would the FAA have been ignored by the general public? I feel like a 4+ hour stop on all planes in the US is going to be front page unless there's something bigger going on.
I agree that correlation doesn't imply causation. At the same time, I think an increase in uncommon events over a relatively short period of time does increase the chance that they are correlated.
Does it increase it enough to make it plausible or likely? No clue. But we've seen similar in Europe, and the consensus among intelligence/military analysts seems to be that Russia and Europe are in a non-military conflict of some sort.
It might be just bad luck here, or the start of something similar.
Would we have heard or cared about this one if the others hadn't already happened?
I don't think it's a stretch to say that some number of services go down every day and we don't hear or care about them. Three or four services going down and/or being attacked over a few days is only a pattern if it's actually different from before vs. you're just more aware about them.
Because then you have to define the "major" and "short" in "major outages in a short timespan", in such a way that
A. Includes all four of those
B. When applied to the past, would actually, meaningfully differ from the status quo (How often can something happen before it's alarming? Once a decade? Twice as often as that? Half as often?)
C. Isn't a clear overfit, threading the needle to meet A and B, but is actually robust against perturbations.
You will likely be right that this is a meaningful period, simply from the flights being grounded and the Microsoft outage, both meaningfully unusual events, but it's very easy to make a fairly challenging assessment seem simple if you just arbitrarily choose things to count on your fingers.
We're in an interesting time when Hanlon's razor seems to be being tested. "Never attribute to malice that which is adequately explained by stupidity".
AI-accelerated attacks, I think most of the cybersecurity ones are attributable to that exploiting previous incompetences. But the flight grounding and microsoft outages? Looks more like direct incompetence to me
Either way I think the takeaway is that we've been slacking for a long time and now we have something that doesn't need man-hours, caffeine, and obsessive human focus to take advantage of that fact. At least for those of us who have been in the field for a while there's lots of work cleaning up these messes for the foreseeable future but I been on calls with peers of mine in infosec who have definitely been losing valuable sleep and health over it
Hanlon's razor reads more to me like a malicious thought terminating cliche than an actual law via averages that still requires testing. Anyone operating with Hanlon's razor can have their perception of anything easily hacked by simply pretending to be stupid, thus converting an act of malicious intent presumably brought about through some motive into an opaque act that requires no further scrutiny.
Agreed, although in common parlance the cliche has has developed more power than it was intended to possess, purely through habitual use. My main point is to point out that it does have a real chilling-like effect within public discourse. I see it most often in commentary about unfolding events. Inquiry into current events creates an impetus for further explanation from information dealers (governments, reporters, etc.) and when that inquiry happens out in the open, it benefits us in the moment and in the historical record. You only get so much attention from a reader and when the content is akin to eating your vegetables, readers look for excuses to clear their plate.
Embrace the nuance of any given situation. Abandon the idea that there even exists a valid explanation in blaming cause on stupidity. The cliche doesn't convey information, its merely a characterization which gives permission to readers to stop further inquiry and our acceptance of this has been trained through basic mimetics. Find comfort in saying "I'm not sure what the attributable cause is" rather than deferring to a pop-sci over generalization of human nature. After that, its simply an effort of fact finding.
I would say the incompetence side also includes decades of 'get er done' attitude towards software design. We've been chasing fashionable frameworks and abstractions that may support velocity for developers, but not deep contemplation of the ramifications of design/architecture. The reward/risk balance was never in favor of slowing down to design secure software, it is in favor of meeting the complex and changing requirements of business as quickly as possible. Tech debt just got more expensive because 'poke it until it breaks' was always an option, but now we can ask an LLM and it can work tirelessly in the same problem space. Time for everyone to grind fundamental CS concepts, and aim to reduce complexity. On the bright side an LLM can help with that as well, just remember to append "make no mistakes" to the end of every prompt!
They could just be asking AI to attack different things and find weaknesses as an attack everything goes down things go down 1 by 1 its more like testing. Or more cynical read it could be the plan to hose the american people for all the AI investment scare them into investing in and allowing ai data centers
4 systems going down in the span of 2 weeks for very different reasons is not atypical though. A more apt analogy would be "4 politicians died in the past week in different parts of the planet for different reasons". If headlines focused on those deaths it would also fuel conspiracy theories.
> Because we don't know they're unrelated.
They might be related! But the burden of proof is not on the null case.
Thank you for explaining how the mind of paranoid conspiracy theorist works. For the rest of us it works like this: four unrelated events get treated as unrelated until there is convincing evidence showing otherwise.
Public companies have 4 days to disclose material cybersecurity incidents, per the SEC.
While this rule doesn't apply to the NSA, speculation that recent down time from these U.S. companies being caused by state-sponsored cyber warfare seems unlikely.
I assume most trusted news networks would have some staff that are cleared so they can read a bit more detailed news, then help frame the messages that go out to the masses.
They have intelligence mouthpiece contacts whom they quote uncritically, because they have no other option. That becomes the new truth through Citogenesis.
The size and scale of something like SIPR, JWICS mean they're interacted with by tens of thousands of people at facilities worldwide on a daily basis as part of their regular relatively mundane work. It would be hard not to notice.
I am just surprised this is not happening all the time, after piling on layers upon layers of software and merely looking for a checkbox to check and someone else to blame (and pay).
Even the vertically integrated tech companies that used to be in control of the whole stack are having their Outlook moments now, everyone else is worse off.
Everyone had to jump off VMware because the price got jacked up, and the people who were forced to rebuild the systems in a hurry weren't the ones who architected them. I'll bet there is a big learning curve for these systems that were slowly optimized over time, but now people are switching to Openshift and whatnot where those optimizations and Lessons Learned are mostly thrown out.
AI cyberattacks, foreign interference, and Ghost in the Shell type stuff sounds cooler though.
Although I don't know the answer, and have not done the work to analyze this situation properly, in cases like this I find it helpful to try to focus primarily on the overall epistemological framework rather than only the matter at hand (since it is easy to get lost in all the uncertainty, lack of knowledge, and presence of disinformation); an especially useful and simple tool here is Bayesian inference.
For instance, I have heard that Iranians have developed rather sophisticated cyber-warfare capabilities. I don't know if that is true, and if true, I don't know how likely it would be that they would have reached capabilities to cause the observed outages. But even if you assume that the probability (or rather degree of belief) is quite small but still realistic, say between 0.1 and 10 percents, than considering the current situation it might be absolutely rational to see it likely that they are behind these outages. The full analysis requires estimation of the probability that this is all just a coincidence, and of other major "non-coincidental" branches. But one can do this at various levels of precision and explicitly observe how the output depends on the priors and the estimated probabilities (and therefore, on the assumptions).
As always: how does Bayes' Theorem and assigning arbitrary percentages shed any light on this topic? If you took any mention of Bayesian inference out of your comment, would it lack any content or insight? I have encountered the concept for years and it just seems to make explicit what everyone already does implicitly. Not that there's no value to that, but I think it's very rare that it's worth invoking.
It is hard to give an answer to a comment like yours since I have no idea at what level are we discussing the topic.
First of all, I have not said that just assigning arbitrary probabilities sheds much light on the matter. Rather, what I alluded to, is that even rough estimates might often shed a lot of light on the topic. The Bayesian formulation helps to separate the problem into relevant parts, make the relative importance and interdependence of various factors that enter the reasoning clearer, and makes the assumptions more explicit. But in my post I have not really explained anything; I have just pointed to a tool somebody interested might use to critically assess similar issues. So yes, if you took it away, the post would lack an important part of its message, namely a pointer to a framework that the OP (or anyone interested) might find useful. However, I do not plan to give a treatise on Bayesian analysis in a HN post.
As for the other angles of your post:
1. Yes, the usage of the framework absolutely can shed light on many matters of this kind. What is your background? How much experience do you have with statistics or inference in general? There are many good sources where you can learn about these methods. A somewhat controversial one, but freely accessible, is E.T. Jaynes' Probability Theory, which actually directly addresses some aspects of what I spoke about.
2."it just seems to make explicit what everyone already does implicitly" People apply very bad judgement to matters like these all the time, this forum included. And even if people all used those things implicitly (which often they don't) it would still be worthwhile since it allows one to inspect the argument and find flaws or observe what are the dependencies on various assumptions.
The deadline for Genesis Mission [0], the US gov project to integrate its systems as well as private systems into a centralized AI platform to deliver its first report is at the end of November.
I saw some speculation here [1] that it might be the root cause.
Yes, there are no legitimate actions in the world. Everything which seems to happen is actually just a pretense so we can justify our actions.
Even more importantly, when these pretextual actions occur, everyone interprets them the same way and agrees that the secretly-planned action is now the one we must take.
In the early days of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, Russia faced a big problem: it had hardly any of the tanks it paid for. Why? Corruption. Basically it worked like this: a general would get money from the Kremlin to design and build new tanks. They'd build a few but for whatever reason they'd be found wanting. So a new contract was written up. But what happened to the money? It got pocketed by the generals, the contractor and a bunch of other people in between.
That's basically what's happening to the US right now. It is corruption from the Oval Office all the way down. Pardons are being openly sold. The news was manipulated ("a ceasefire is imminent") to profit off the oil markets. Stock trades on insider information abound. All of this is an inevitable consequence from a Supreme Court who manufactured out of thin air substantial criminal immunity for the president. This built on other decisions where this Court in particular just could not see corruption (eg Snyder v. United States [1]).
In the private sector literally nobody is ever punished for cost-cutting on systems to the point that they break. In fact, they're rewarded for it. It's entshittification from the CEOs all the way down.
We'll probably find as more of these incidents happen that AI code was written and reviewed by another AI, never tested and deployed to production. Foreign actors will be blamed, Congress will be blamed, etc. As an aside, the DoT is asking for $50 billion after the FAA outage (the worst in 25 years). Then Representative Mullin voted against $25 billion for the FAA in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act in 2021 [2].
Now the administration wants to sell this narrative that they've been hacked. No, they're just corrupt and everything sucks as an inevitable result. Everything is shit. Nobody is hacking us.
I honestly don't know how we get out of this but we need a hard reset of some sort. One such hard reset was the French Revolution. There are an awful lot of people who need to spend the rest of their lives in jail, penniless.
I wonder that the said network looks like. I’ll never know because I don’t work there. Do we get any genuine insider look maybe for the same network 20 years ago?
Or is it close to a large corporation network built on MSFT stack?
Very true. It is an bot-managed (infested) engagement engine, not a credible source for most things any more. They are driving the narratives that they need in order for them to keep eyeballs on the site. I found this job listing [0] under "Computer Gigs" sidebar for the Dallas Craigslist. I suspect that there are similar opportunities all over the country.
Reddit is done. I'm so glad I got perma-banned by their AI mod. Though the meat-space mods lifted the ban on appeal, I had a long enough interval that I unwound all engagement. I found reddit right after they launched and have spent a lot of time over the last 20 years on various subs. That's all over now.
FWIW, I had a summer internship 40 years at BBN, working on the obsolete and soon-to-be-retired switches running the ARPAnet; one of their other customers was the NSA.
I'm pretty sure they were calling that network the NSANet back then; I assume it's gone through many generations of upgrade since then. I don't remember much about them as a customer, except that (a) we weren't supposed to mention their name, and (b) they were running a horribly old version of the switch firmware. My understanding was that they literally tested stuff for years before deploying it.
It was a long time ago, and I was just a summer hire, so I could have this wrong; in addition things may have changed in the intervening 40 years.
I’ve been peripherally involved in builds of “very high security private networks” for government.
It’s ass backwards.
The entire process is about compliance, the actual security is totally ignored.
One vendor I spoke to was scouring eBay for old Juniper VPN appliances that still had some ancient firmware that could no longer be “downgraded to” on new ones.
Notably, this old firmware included the back door used by the Chinese government that was trivially exploitable! [1]
Why that version!?
“Because that specific point release was certified years ago, and they never updated the certification subsequently.” was the almost verbatim explanation!
It’s insane, but that’s how government drones think. You can’t snap them out of it, they’re unable to comprehend any other way of doing things.
Details like “security is a treadmill, you have to keep moving” just doesn’t compute.
Hopefully we are able to learn lessons from our own mistakes now instead of finding out when enemies find them later. I am hopeful AI makes it easier to find these mistakes and plug holes faster than they can be found.
What I haven't seen mentioned is whether it's possible that these are a rogue or state-controlled AI cyber-attack and it's just doing a really good job at covering its tracks?
I think that's a good question, but my follow-up would be: what's the motive of not taking credit for it? The attacks are hurting the economy and sowing fear, but not by much when you put them all together. So it seems like the very best motive would be to claim credit.
To me, if Iran or one of their allies did it, they would love to take credit for it as proof that not only is the U.S. vulnerable, it's vulnerable to them. I think that would give them credibility with their peers around the world show they can give the US a black eye.
But to your point if somebody like North Korea did it, they wouldn't brag about it but they'd be talking quietly to their friends and maybe even taking orders for the next target.
Or it's too humiliating, or too close to national defense secrets, to publicly admit what it is. Imagine if it's some sort of "Die Hard 3" -style threat made by Putin: "Don't attack my refineries or I'll shut down your industries — here's a shut down of your NSA for proof."
There are a bunch of people here speculating like that... At least one comment was older than yours. "Could AI have done this?" comments are at their peak ever since the huggingface thing. Speculation that problems are due to vibe coding is also up there.
Is it going to cause serious or grave damage to the United States’ national interest if China knows that the nsa's intranet was impacted for a morning?
No. You might be able to conjure some scenario up, but the answer is no. And that is the basis for classifying things.
And further, there's a public interest in knowing if one of the premier intelligence agencies is so dysfunctional that they cannot even keep their computers connected.
It would help if the moment the service came back online the title of the post could be changed to (FIXED) or something
Like the United Airlines thing yesterday, the moment I got to the article it said "was down for a few hours" but the post was still just something about United Airlines network being offline
Give it a minute. Bespoke networks fall down all the time. We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures. It is a self-fulfilling prophecy. As we become more sensitive to outages, every normal everyday outage becomes part of the global pattern.
If the network was one of those no-fail important ones (think NORAD stuff) then nobody would be talking about it as doing so would be treasonous. So, at most, this is a less-important internal network. It will probably be back up by end of business.
There's even a name for this fallacy: it's called the frequency illusion [0]
> The frequency illusion, also known as the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, is a cognitive bias in which a person notices a specific concept, word, or product more frequently after recently becoming aware of it.
Also drone/UFO "Flaps". If ATC tells pilots that a drone has been seen near an airport, every scrap of paper, every possible light in the sky becomes a quadcopter. Flaps have actually shut down major airports, even though nothing is ever photographed let alone found.
>> Flap, originally a military term to describe a "period of panic or chaos", is used by ufologists to describe surges of sightings in one geographical area. Longer surges spanning multiple countries may be called waves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UFO_flap
What happens is that the media catches whiff of a new fear, and goes to work harvesting it for every last ad-view. Each story amps up the fear too, so it becomes a flywheel of money.
Anything the catches the public's collective conscious, the media is there to stoke it into piles of ad dollars.
Any journalist worth their pay is paying close attention to what is getting traction on social media.
It's extremely profitable to write stories telling social media pitchfork mobs how correct they are. Influencers have been catching onto this game in the last decade too, and went from "here is what is actually going on" contrarians to "here is what is actually going on" agenda towing. It just pays so much more, and people trust you more (because people naturally trust those who tell them they are right).
> Give it a minute. Bespoke networks fall down all the time.
Including NSA Net? How often does it fall down?
> We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures
This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time. Which also hints that NSA Net failures happen with some kind of regularity and that that news orgs had been getting wind of it.
I suspect that the opposite is true. That it's rare to unheard of for NSA Net to fail like this and rare for a news org to get wind of something so deeply protected.
Following the series of such events over the past couple of days, I have to say I’m a bit surprised by how quickly some in this community are brushing them off as AI-related pain or simply another example of the clickbait-driven media ecosystem.
I understand the skepticism, and I certainly don’t think we should go down a rabbit hole of conspiracy theories. But shouldn’t we also be a little skeptical of dismissing these events so quickly? Is it unreasonable to at least consider the possibility that they’re not entirely coincidental, or to wonder why so many seem to be taking place in the US?
IMO it's unreasonable not to think they are all related in some way, even if that relation is just bad actors seeing what other bad actors have been capable of recently. This all started with the freezers in Europe and seems to be snowballing since.
In reality, this has been ongoing this whole year and you are only now seeing it in the media.
Companies have been wide open in all sorts of ways for decades, and basically just surviving by flying under the radar of script kiddies.
That changed. Now script kiddies or average criminal orgs feel more able to just pick their targets, and it's an extremely target rich environment.
That a lot of businesses are finally taking drastic action sort of tells you how much they were willingly ignoring the issue previously. Everything everywhere was very insecure. It was just surviving from a lack of attackers.
Top level management, like investor level, still thinks this is just something to be fixed by applying a new magic word too, like "buy another security scanner" or "just use AI to fix the problem"
If there is a connection, then my guess would be that some AI systems became ready. However, I would only consider that credible in case of the NSA if they have decided to pull the plug on their network itself, for example to stop data exfiltration or as a general protective measure against newly found exploits that require large changes. Other than NK and Iran, I see no nation state currently having a good reason to attack US intelligence destructively, and I don't find it likely Iran or NK have the ability. It certainly doesn't make sense for Russia or China to attack the US right now.
It's AI. Or more specifically: rushed, careless usage of AI under the pretense that it's already "solved" software and you can haphazardly push junk to the world and expect real systems to run on it.
Traditional software development normally involves at least a few veterans on the team familiar with almost every line of code.
However, AI works like a speedy intern who hasn't yet got to grips with the whole codebase, and sometimes makes assumptions. That's mostly because the codebase is usually bigger than the context window, so it is 'writing blind'.
The news and the blogosphere. Everyone is high on AI and so much more "productive" not reading generated code anymore, let alone writing code manually. And all developers have been let go because AI is cheaper this week.
I feel like this is attention bias. A government built messaging service used by one agency for a subset of their data isn't going to have 3 nines in the first place.
Why not, that seems like a pretty well understood scope and scale. GitHub going down because it has 400 interdependent systems and a billion new users is more understandable.
... and Doug's perl script, which was never committed to source control. It lives on a single box and silently upholds a number of implicit system invariants. In someones inbox is an email from Doug, sent just before he retired, that the script needs to be copied over to the new box before the hardware migration is complete.
I have this distinct memory in I think Jan 2020 where I looked at the front page of CNN or NYT or something. Big picture of Trump impeachment, and proceedings. Small picture at the bottom of the page of China dealing with this virus. Worthy news, but not top page news. Nobody was paying attention. Feb, more people started paying attention, but it wasn't top page yet. By March, people were starting to realize that this is a serious crisis that's going to severely impact their lives.
I'm getting Feb 2020 vibes. I don't know what's going on, but this feels like more than just some routine outages going on.
The fantasy/cyberpunk TTRPG Shadowrun depicted a world in upheaval after a global computer crash in the late 2020s. In addition to the pandemics and the AIs.
I'll probably get downvoted for this but I feel like CNN stopped being a serious source of journalism a long time ago (along with Fox and most of the networks). A real story is the exception, so it's hard for me to take most of these things seriously.
Have you considered endorsing a better source instead of just disparaging the rest and leaving us to guess how we're supposed to achieve enlightenment? "Trust no one" is not a winning strategy.
funny I sat there for a minute thinking to myself.. I should provide a better source. I came up blank. Sorry. I could probably go on and on about independent journalism, but it's probably healthier to just turn it all off and go outside.
Washington reportedly did say that but it had previously been attributed to Mark Twain, though apparently there's no good evidence for that.
The sentiment is quite old, however. Thomas Jefferson wrote in 1807: ...the man who never looks into a newspaper is better informed than he who reads them; inasmuch as he who knows nothing is nearer to truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods & errors.
I think it just takes too much effort sometimes to sift through the b.s. that MSM uses to pay for its real news. Like if you look at CNN's front page and Fox's front page the core is the same: they're just using words and images to inflame people who follow their bias. Both outlets often break real news though.
Where it gets interesting is the "Exclusive" part of the headline. Like somebody else said, any other source would either have to have access to people similar to CNN's "six people familiar with the matter" or else reference CNN.
The fact that Reuters amplified the story (and attributed it to CNN) gives it a little more weight.
Allowing our infrastructure to be manufactured elsewhere, maintained by companies who struggle to retain top talent, and overseen by folks out of touch with cutting edge threats, and funded on annual budget cycles by legislators even more out-of-touch ... is a seemingly insurmountable set of obstacles.
I have also been curious about frequency bias / Baader–Meinhof - but I am also wondering: what are the chances that a state actor is responsible for the last week of issues?
Trump is headed to China for a meeting with Xi and Putin.
We have 3 carriers off the coast of Iran and (despite Trump's pleas) NATO is essentially pushing their boot into Putin's neck w/ continued Ukrainian strikes on Russian oil infra.
I've seen a few takes from L3 Harris / FAA employees calling the official line about the ATC issue bunk and there are 3 other major issues in the last week, now this NSA outage - curious if these incidents could be the BRICS axis flexing their own cybermuscles (independently in multiple separate attacks with carefully placed assets) ahead of their meeting with Trump in China?
An interesting geopolitical Mexican standoff, if true.
I'm not claiming this is true. I'm literally pulling it out of my rear with little context beyond a bunch of random news stories and X posts, it's pure pedestrian speculation / curiosity.
Would love someone steeped in national security / geopolitics (like: professionally as their job, not armchair analysts) to offer their take on this.
>NATO is essentially pushing their boot into Putin's neck w/ continued Ukrainian strikes on Russian oil infra.
I know it's not the thrust of your post, but I see this or similar framing a lot, and I feel compelled to point out that Putin can end the strikes on his oil infrastructure at any time by ending the war he started by invading another country.
* From a purely moral / ethical standpoint: it is good that this is happening, Russia "deserves" this and brought it upon themselves.
* This nonetheless has geopolitical implications. The less oil Russia has to sell to China, the more buy pressure there is elsewhere, the higher the price of oil is generally and thus the higher competition for resources / tensions are between great powers.
* Ukraine is doing a lot of the heavy lifting in many areas themselves these days, NATO could honestly be doing more. However: what Ukraine is able to do themselves does owe something to the financial and material support they have enjoyed (historically from both the US and NATO, currently more from NATO only) in that they are able to allocate their own efforts with according relative "ease"
* It makes sense to me that, given the US' power within NATO, Russia and its BRICS partners would try to apply pressure to the US to encourage NATO to provide even LESS support to Ukraine (or outright become antagonistic against Ukraine, to the extent we aren't already) in whatever way they could.
Yeah. We're not giving Ukraine enough credit. It's Ukraine pushing its boot into Putin's neck with a frankly underwhelming amount of support from NATO. The Russian humiliation at the Kerch bridge yesterday was all Ukranian munitions.
I suppose rather than straight up 'cyberattack', that some kind of sabotage is also possible... but I don't see how that could ever really be proven without massive state-level investigations... at which point people will also question whether they are themselves involved somehow.
Right - sabotage was my thought as well in some cases (with the placed assets I'm suggesting).
I don't know how it could be proven either, I'm just curious if it is plausible or even likely from the perspective of someone who knows more than me about NatSec / geopolitical issues.
Nothing ever happens. But if it goes down, there's hoping that some of our day-to-day services go back to their offline roots again, like money being a real thing you can hold in your hand, and your software running on your own device and not someone else's server.
Where can you even find information about how it's secured? Also, are they monitoring for security or for everyday bugs? Is this high-assurance software running on high-assurance systems?
NSA seems to have deprioritized information assurance over the past decade or so and now the chickens are coming home to roost.
Someone who wants to launch a Y2K-style hardening business (LLMS to look for problems, humans+LLMs to fix them) could really make bank right now. Maybe there will be a cuple in the next YC batch.
Weirder to me is that some of these recent stories have been CNN exclusives (filed under Politics) and CNN is now owned by Skydance (Ellison) which is anything but a unbiased actor.
Knowledge of the existence of the network isn't the same as knowledge of what traffic flows across it.
Just like good crypto must survive robust cryptanalysis, good network security needs to be robust even when adversaries know the network exists (and perhaps even where in physical space key nodes are located).
That being said: the network being down isn't something that immediately makes me worried in the near term. "Turn it off" is a better first response than "observe if anything seems weird" for communications channels that prioritize secrecy over availability.
All bits of classified information have to have justification to be classified. Typically unless its a critical classified network (think operational/urgent military comms) then the status of the network is usually not classified. Its only classified if a good argument can be made that the status is a national security risk. Usually its preferred to have as little as possible classified as its a great hindrance to fixing or getting things done because of all the overhead of security, meetings and paperwork involved.
I don't like it when they use that phrasing because all it really means is "we called them and nobody picked up", or they simply didn't have a response ready at the time... which shouldn't imply anything at all. Most people don't immediately return messages.
True but what's particularly funny in this case is this is not an organization that ever communicates. In other words it would be appropriate to see this for say a public business that is communicating all the time
I think the most likely culprit is Broadcom jacking the prices of VMWare so high that everyone's scrambling to get off of it ASAP, leading to poor rebuilds of systems by people who don't understand them.
There is a fine line between attributing this to mass conspiracy and cyber attack (which no one wants to believe) and attributing this to random bugs popping everywhere. Too many people are eager to cross this line. While others are trying to stay behind it.
The truth lies somewhere in the middle. My theory: someone figured out how to bring down each network. And is progressively breaking each system to help developers fix their security holes. Given enough breaks, we will figure out their modus operandi. And then figure out who they are.
Or something even more conspiratorial: us govt is halting each system to install back doors.
This country continues day after day to get exactly what we voted for. Incompetant old men who would rather play golf and point fingers than take any form of decisive leadership and fix things.
(I'm not saying the dems would do better, i'm saying we all need to stop voting for old men in primaries because they are more "electable")
Conspiracy theories are flying, but don't you think that enough people are involved in maintaining these systems that if it was, for example, an attack by a foreign country, it would have leaked from one of the tens of thousands of people involved?
Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now because it causes fear, and fear gets clicks. Now think about how many major networks have a problem in a given week. You just never hear about them until now.
> don't you think that [...] it would have leaked from one of the tens of thousands of people involved?
No I don't. Why would you risk your career and potentially your freedom to leak a report about enemy action, in which doing so could potentially harm your country too?
So we are to believe that 6 people leaked the fact that the classified NSA network is down, but also no one is willing to leak evidence of widespread cyber attacks?
The 6 people that “leaked” the outage are likely executive leaders in the organization and also being very careful to not release information that would actually pose a threat to national security. It’s pretty common in DC, see David Pozen’s article The Leaky Leviathan[0]. These people are sometimes prosecuted (see Gen. James Cartwright) but it’s rare because it’s both tacitly understood as necessary to allow for coordination with the rest of the government and american society, and they take effort to color within the lines.
Besides recency bias, another problem with this specific outage story or really anything to do with current national security/defense matters is that by definition only uninformed opinions are widely available. "Those who know don't talk, those who talk don't know" – excluding one-in-a-generation whistleblowers like Snowden, and even those are necessarily limited to one-time snapshots because once they disclose they are shut out and (presumably?) methods, technologies, and operations change afterward.
I doubt this is the case, but since we're talking about conspiracy theories: this looks more like things breaking by accident as things are shimmed for control by a third party and less like a focused attack.
>Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now
It's exactly like the media reporting every aviation notice after an airplane crash. Leading people to speculate "why is everything broken right now!" even though it's the normal course of business, they're only just noticing it now because they're being told to notice it.
There's some speculation that all of these recent outages might be related to attempts at taking Genesis Mission online - the Trump / Oracle project to have AI tie into government and private services:
I’ve heard people suggest this is growing pains for the Genesis Mission coming online (we’re hitting the one year mark, and they may be a little cavalier trying to meet their timeline).
No, it’s across the government and headed by the department of energy. The nominal goal is to achieve advances in scientific research, but it gets there by connecting all of the disparate networks across agencies (and creates a “superintelligence”)
Well, Nasdaq is down 2%. "On the news", and on every single other piece of news that's out there. Tracing it to any one piece of news is usually pure guesswork.
It was. They've been on a streak of journalistic malpractice recently - including an egregious example a few years ago where they slandered and doxxed a minor.
Okay, but let's ask why there might have been missing knowledge/competencies/people, leading to "stupidity": the current US government has deliberately massively decreased the value of positions in public service. It's only reasonable to assume that the best people left, considering their job security was more reliant on the opinion of unqualified "hackers" and ChatGPT than on their own job performance.
We just had a full ground stop of all flights, and a major banking outage yesterday, following a major microsoft outage. I am starting to have doubts about them not being related.
> theres some sort of strategy of tension regarding cyber/fraility of systems being pushed.
> 'Manufacturing Consent', new Congress AI regulation for industry capture in the pipeline
both capture my inclinations, but the other thing is this can simply be symptoms/indicators. looking at the recent faa thing, this could be "move fast and break things" happening in real time.
new contractors, new programs, more outsourcing/privatizations etc, palantir type companies moving into new places.
this is right after midterms, so the admin is doing its final phase of plays
AI is tuned to speak confidently and ship independently; it is rare that it will suggest that one go back to a broad survey of stakeholders to ensure no Chesterton's Fence is being torn down (https://fs.blog/chestertons-fence/). "I've read the documentation and logs, and nothing suggests this system needs these legacy capabilities/components/capacity" is something we hear all day, and it is a siren's song if there ever was one.
Couple that with a general (and valid!) consensus that modernization of legacy systems must be accelerated for a variety of reasons - to mitigate this new and continuing "Black October" of hyper-agile agent-driven cyberattacks (whether the network is public or private); to have more flexible infrastructure for new features to stay ahead; to allow human teams to show their efficacy in a world where technology jobs are increasingly at risk - and you have a perfect storm where change management is no longer what it once was.
Some weeks ago, our Claude subscription failed - most people stopped working and switched to tasks they had postponed.
I suspect the situation is that AI's caveats are just easier to ignore than a person's warnings. Plus all the other factors you list. Also, AI tends to give a person the kind of communication they ask for. I always ask for options but I suspect other people ask for just answer and so they get them.
Doesn't stop so many people from believing it wholesale, and doesn't prevent so many programmers from saying "I don't review code anymore"
Asking the coin-tossing machine if it's safe until it says it's safe. :)
I think you went off somewhere else.
Which is to say, a parent post here on HN doesn't narrow the topic to it's focus. That's what makes discussion here interesting.
The FAA's recent outage for example, at its core, seems like people trying to rush needed upgrades that were slow for a specific reason (e.g. reducing the testing window for 90 to 30-days).
The Microsoft outage seems like three different things linked together (and poor "full failure" recovery prep, lengthening the outage).
The bank "outage" may not have even existed, 2/3 of the banks claimed they didn't have an outage at all, and the other said it was a limited technical issue. The articles were based on DownDetector spikes.
This is just a media hype train. Zelle outages have happened many times before but the stories didn't blow up they way they are now.
This has reached a Witch-hunt levels of fever pitch.
You'll commonly get regional failures, when failure happens.
You're out here categorically saying none of these had an AI or cyber-attack angle with no verifiable proof and having a tantrum that other people are doing the same thing in reverse.
The list of unanswered questions is long. Maybe focus on pushing for more details instead of immediately saying "nothing to see here" regarding a series of important failures within a week's time.
BTW here's JPMorganChase's statement: > JPMorganChase has experienced a temporary issue related to a software bug in on-premise hardware systems – there is no evidence this is cyber-related. Where we were party to a transaction involving other banks, those banks may have been impacted, but this is not a systemic issue. Customers still have access to their accounts and funds.
If you were trying to send your rent payment via Zelle from your Citibank account to your landlord's Chase account and it continually failed yesterday with no clear reason immediately provided, of course any complaint is a "witch hunt" since your Citibank account "works."
it wouldve been easy for the faa to blame their new AI vendor or these companies to blame some new ai process set up by consultants etc...
So let me see if I understand what I should be:
- Be more skeptical of official explanations, including where it includes a technical breakdown of how it occurred (e.g. Microsoft/Outlook outage).
- Be less skeptical of random commenters claiming, without proof, that it is AI or Cyber Attacks.
Because that's the implied point you're making. Be more skeptical of A and less skeptical of B, even though A has someone placing their reputation behind it, and B is anonymous commenters throwing made up theories out into the ether.
The explanation for this one still doesn't ring true for me and that's exacerbated by how many times the story has changed after telling the public that they didn't need to know the reasons.
Agree, though, that the rest do have reasonable explanations
So this outage seems a bit overdue to me.
Is "Claude says it looks good so let's skip the usual testing window and push to prod on a Friday" really not a sentence you can imagine being said in this current environment?
My point is that people are taking a potential future problem and applying to actual things that have recently happened, that didn't fit that mold. Which is incorrect.
When AI or Cyber Attacks cause an outage, people are absolutely right to say so. But claiming - without proof, that every outage is related to the two is noise.
In my line of work I deal with a lot of banks. They have been absolutely panicked for the last few months as they have been using AI to find and exploit bugs in their own software (A huge number of banks are members of project glasswing and other AI cyber testing with less limits than the public ones we get). This has forced them to drop almost everything else and immediately address updates in their systems, especially to a lot of legacy software that's sat around forever.
Just this many updates is going to cause instability in itself. Old systems that aren't touched can run forever without many problems, but when you can RCE said app the normal 3+ months of testing goes out the window. Now imagine this with tons of bugs in hundreds or thousands of applications at a single bank and you can see why things are starting to get unstable.
Naturally, when you tell an entire occupation that they are no longer necessary employees and that AI writes all your code, when something breaks in a major way those people are probably going to ask the question.
(https://www.cnbc.com/2025/04/29/satya-nadella-says-as-much-a...)
Summer of 2019 was also a pretty good one [2].
I fully expect AI will cause insane disruptions at some point, but all evidence points to this just being a series of normal outages. Worst timing ever to have a patch Tuesday.
[1] https://www.csmonitor.com/USA/USA-Update/2015/0708/NYSE-Unit... [2] https://www.thousandeyes.com/blog/looking-back-biggest-inter...
As a developer, I know very well that systems break, sometimes frequently (AI or not). It has always been the case, and likely always will be the case.
But, I am not surprised that people are mentioning AI - feels like most posts on here for the last year have involved AI in some capacity.
https://www.bleepingcomputer.com/news/security/optimizely-su...
Is it possible that the false of productivity is leading to worse products and massive loss in valuable headcount? Instead of AIs directly writing bad buggy code? Or is "everything rage-bait, and AI is all sunshine"
There's a group of people who think AI is perfect and will solve all of humanity's problems. That's annoying. There's another group of people who think AI is the worst thing to ever happen to humanity and is the downfall of society. These people are more vocal in my experience and they're everywhere. If you ever use AI you're a bad person who they'll disown like you're racist. It's somehow become the most popular 'social justice' issue of our time even as ICE exists alongside it. These people see a problem and immediately try to figure out how AI is involved. That's far more annoying.
Best example I can give that came up in my circle recently is the video game "Big Walk". It was recently denied for a silly award nomination because the awards have a strict no-AI policy. Which to me is absolutely fine, go nuts. But the vitriol towards this game, that everybody absolutely ADORED before the developer disclosed that they fixed ~10 lines (!) of code with AI because they couldn't figure it out otherwise, is absolutely bonkers. People I respect treated it like they were mourning something that WAS great until this catastrophe happened.
It would be interesting if someone could do a proper analysis, though!
It would hardly be shocking that hostile nations are able to cause some problems with Mythos level tools.
If anything, it is more interesting how we can invade another country and the idea that the country or a collection of hostile countries could hit us back in any way, shape or form is just an impossibility. An insane conspiracy theory.
Maybe it is not that but surely the probablity is not zero.
I can't put my finger on it, but something sinister feels afoot.
Frankly, for the past few days, my gut is pushing a hypothesis to explain why nothing happened yet: bad actors are holding off until the winter starts.
https://beready.campaign.gov.uk/
It's nowhere near the kind of readiness and preparedness campaigns of the cold-war of course, but it's a step up in alertness that's higher than anything I can remember.
Too many people are addicted to their smartphones and don't feel the same level of pride they used to in their work. All systems are shared, instead of one person being the ruler of a certain part of the stack, it's a revolving door and it's rare that anyone stays somewhere for even 5-10yrs. It leaves a wake of modifications that nobody else can keep up with. Also, the tech industry is moving fast just to move fast, a lot of old infra is still C++ and COBOL but good luck hiring anyone to use that, so they have to convert the systems to use the Latest Tech of the Day. The old, stable people don't have any interest in learning the new thing, and would rather retire with their knowledge. The new people want to rebuild from scratch in the New Thing and are convinced they need to job hop immediately after.
There are now post mortems for both outages. The FAA outage was caused by a botched upgrade to an ancient system. The MSFT outage was caused by a latent concurrency bug that was surfaced by a later incident. My experience in this industry tells me that this is plausible because these are exactly the type of things that tend to cause outages. My industry experience also tells me that hundreds to thousands of people were involved in the responses to these incidents, so if the companies were lying about the cause it would be leaked to the press and posted about all over Blind.
The other outages all seem to be normal nothing burger outages that happen all the time and nobody ever hears about because they don't make the news or even the front page of HN. The reason they make the news now is most likely because we just had the MSFT / FAA outages and that's in the news cycle now, not because they are somehow linked.
I can put my finger on it, and nothing sinister is afoot.
[To be clear: I mean exactly what I said, which is "there could be" which is not the same as "I think there is" -- so call it a 5%-10% chance of real cyberwarfare -- which means I'm not dismissing those claims out of hand, and find the claims at least plausible, even if I don't currently believe them]
It’s not nothing
But my gut says incompetence and rushing upgrades out of fear of cyberwarfare, not an actual attack.
Though at the same time, the public isn't privy to even 10% of the incidents going on right now.
The information I have is consistent with general cybercrime and script kiddie patterns, just a much higher volume, and much larger diversity of targets.
You have aides and resources and money. Not having enough information or understanding is a choice.
It's criminal negligence.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequency_illusion
Combine this with news reflecting both supply and demand for stories, it's impossible to tell. There's certainly a constant supply of outages.
I also think generally that AI is probably both the cause and solution to these problems. We're certainly getting more code churn than otherwise, and in lots of cases that's really good! But you're going to have to deal with inevitable instability too.
I'm sure most of us here have been on the receiving end of managers suddenly obsessed with a failure mode because it happened to occur twice in one month.
(This of course is on top of whatever unusual things might actually be happening)
I think the real ones were the Microsoft and FAA due to deploying the AI slop.
The other ones seem to be usual outages that normally no one reports on.
But I'd note, these "named after a thing" phenomena (eponnyms) are kind of terrible for exact description since their definition tends to be fuzzy, there's a temptation to fudge their borders and they create an insider jargon (if only I could a device that could reach of the computer and slap everyone who says "steelman" when they mean strengthen an argument, etc).
So certainly there is a big social-psychological phenomenon. Or it's gonna be a cold winter! :)
The combination is a cycle
1. AI finds bugs
2. Engineers us AI to try and fix
3. AI testing approves, minimal engineering review
4. Engineers push release rapidly, it's critical after all
5. Bugs introduced
6. Cycle starts again
With all the recent asshattery of leaking kernel exploits, I would presume trust is gone, and it's cover the big boys first.
(a linux kernel bug vulnerability could be patched without lkml involvement or distros even knowing)
I imagine, for the paranoid spy, not being able to call home could also mean "the enemy has severed our comms, we've been compromised, burn everything and run!".
Of course, it might be a limited hangout to soften the blow of actually being compromised.
So much reporting about clandestine activities falls apart because the traditional 5 Ws of journalism cannot be attributed.
1. say nothing in an official capacity and let people speculate
2. make an official announcement to head-off any concerns and speculation
Anybody that doesn't understand there is a classified plan to internally destabilize whether through legitimate exploits or planned accidents is woefully unaware of the history of the DoD and CIA.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Northwoods
Its either that systems are starting to decay because everyone is rapidly offshoring all the hard parts of their jobs to mediocre chat bots..
Or they're actually trying to cause some sort of public stress about the frailty of systems.. They dont go around publishing that their critical systems are going down. It is odd.
I find it more likely that NSANet status is not classified than I do that 5 people committed a felony to tell CNN this information...
Yeah, you can do fine with only one set of eyes on a problem. Yeah, it is more "efficient" in the short term. Culling lots of do-nothing people in your organization isn't going to produce many tears. Even so, devs and IT departments are now missing all sorts of backup and vital personnel that keep the gears oiled and running.
This is doubly true at this time of year, when we're likely to see people pushing to get work delivered by the end of December so that they can include it in yearly reviews. I'll happily merge PRs I don't understand if that's what keeps my job.
Then it is a failure of software dev individualism. There is a long-proven, battle-tested solution to management making unreasonable demands from labor: Unionization.
I'd be more willing to believe the network in question here was under an attack load that either was probed or exploited far enough that shutting it down was worthwhile. It seems more reasonable to me than believing they've let AI run amok on their internals such that it's now failing.
Not because I'm deifying the NSA but because the system has to be decades old, at least, and I wouldn't expect significant changes to something that "just works".
https://google.github.io/building-secure-and-reliable-system...
GSA's 18F played a major role in applying Site Reliability Engineering (SRE) and modern DevOps practices to federal government infrastructure.
Who decides when a DDOS of Trumpcare.gov that is traced back to Akamai servers was an attempt to extort government contracts or “those pesky Chinese state actors”?
https://www.gsaig.gov/sites/default/files/management-challen...
The problem is much more systemic than having 1 decent org.
That would mean nobody would face any personal responsibility for the damage they've caused. The main reason this hasn't been done on such a massive scale before is the political backlash. And Trump simply doesn't give a damn about that.
On a serious note, I see it as a paradox. Competency is built through struggles, and the non-competent do not want someone that seemed lesser at some point to outrank them, be the go to person.
if only hunger wasn't an issue
But give it another year, trust me bro.
It does? Can you share an objective metrics that can highlight this that doesn't focus on single, isolated events?
I know you'll provide this because of your strong anti-"trust me bro" stance and dedication to scientific fact.
That's just going off the top of my head in the past 5 days
The only thing that distinguishes this particular moment in time is the thousands of bots from companies preparing for an IPO.
Coincidence or is there some common explanation that I missed?
I think the opportunity right now where we have powerful AI hacking systems but not enough protections is to establish long-term presence in all networks of interest. Not bring them down.
For example, we updated a GCP managed base image of Ubuntu that was released with 350 CVEs patched, some were as high as 9.8. In doing so, they (GCP) changed the DEFAULT setting for hardware GRO from off by default to on. That's a massive networking change packed into a security update.
We only caught it AFTER it started causing issues in production. We didn't have the OS pinned because (decently valid reasons) or catch it in non-prod (decent reason + human mistake).
This is on a modern highly automated tested resilient well architected platform.
I can only imagine these other platforms are dramatically more exposed that we are, hence these common large scale outages.
More plausible to me is that spy agencies had previously found and used some of these hundreds or thousands of vulnerabilities to hack into those networks just fine. But now other people like cyber criminals are using these vulnerabilities via AI. That is messing up both the attackers who had already gotten in quietly and do not want the attention and the defenders who now have to respond to a noisy intrusion they cannot ignore.
Outages could be grey-hat testers and emergency updates.
A temporary period like we are experiencing is to be expected when moving to a time where a single engineer can perform the equivalent work of a team of excellent engineers working for weeks. Security has always been a game of who has the capabilities, means, and requirement for any given attack surface.
1. All flights grounded
2. Microsoft outage
3. Optimizely malware
4. Classified NSA network down
I don't know what, but something is clearly happening.
There are a couple of things to keep in mind with nsanet though:
- It can handle anywhere between confidential to TS//SCI information
- It is largely (completely?) an off-infra network, meaning that it doesn't run over the same infrastructure that the open internet uses. It uses an entirely(?) discrete backbone. SIPRNET uses similar architecture.
- You cannot easily cross pollinate data from unclassified networks to nsanet. Everything from removable media to EMSEC is considered prohibited without proper channels being informed and paperwork being performed.
- Lastly, we're unaware of the timing of this supposed source. This could have been over the last week or a month ago or <n>. Scant detail is given, so I'm unwilling to believe "lolz nsa pwnd" just yet.
I would not be surprised if something similar was involved here. It worked with stuxnet, too.
Beyond that it's also typically blocked by GPO prohibiting USB, so even if that were the case, the net result would be no real data transfer and a nice email to the DA mailgroup about the workstation and logged in user who triggered the alert.
Unspecified computer parts were interdicted by US intelligence while being shipped to Neda Industrial and infected with Stuxnet. Four other external vendors working on the enrichment plant were also compromised, likely by Israeli intelligence physically entering buildings.
Stuxnet then spread across each companies internal networks and onto USB drives that were then carried into the facility and plugged into the air gapped network.
https://gdmissionsystems.com/encryption/taclane-network-encr...
Aren't these being treated as "normal" outages by the media and powers that be?
We collectively are very much in arm-chair speculation at this point. If this is a coordinated cyber attack the US government right now wouldn't want to demonstrate weakness or fault. Iran would be the obvious culprit... but going full arm-chair on speculation... There was a major and disappointing result in our elections to the current powers that be...
If this was a staged set of attacks carefully done to minimize casualties... I bet it would be enough to declare a state of emergency and get additional executive powers "legitimately". If that was the case I would expect more propaganda and less bury it under the rug if that was going on.
Be careful out there the world is scary. Don't take any of this as fact, this is all personal speculation based on my own observations. Let me stand-up from my armchair and go for a walk...
- Epstein/SV network within the US flexing muscles in response to mid term losses
- Iran, obviously
- China, obviously
- Russia, obviously
- CIA attacking other parts of the deep state in some internecine struggle or other
Literally all of those are completely plausible scenarios where the actors are motivated and capable
Based on my personal experience and to a certain extent sitting back down in my arm chair. I don't believe this is either China or Russia, they both have priorities that don't immediately involve the US and (as a government) the US is actively supporting both right now in very desirable (to them) ways.
Internal US action and Iran both seem equally likely in my head right now, but this is purely speculation and attribution is the hardest part to actually nail down when a state actor is involved.
This and the continued outages, such as the new Apple services outage, all collectively feel to close together without some evidence of a shared infrastructure causing it or a coordinated attack.
I don't personally believe this is "AI agents hacking the planet". The companies involved (well at least half of the outages I've seen) have enough compliance and protection obligations they are regularly audited against that my Occam's Razor gut feeling tells me that this is either long established persistent and maintained access being detonated one-by-one OR its a focused attack by one or more teams under the same directive taking down significant US focused institutions for attack or reprisal.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Apophenia
While all flights grounded is significant on it's own, and would have got press, even in a world where the fear of AI or foreign interference wasn't so strong, but there's been more than a few substantial local and regional groundings due to software over the past 4-5 years.
Microsoft outage is not new, Teams and Outlook have had more than a handful of outages way before the current doomer craze. While I had to search these for accurate recall, having worked closely with Microsoft for a decade plus, the recent outage is not isolated and to jump to conclusions is short sighted. For example, pre-doomsday summary of Microsoft's noteworthy outages: (1) Azure Outage -Sep 2018 South Central US (San Antonio DC); (2) Recurring multi-day Teams outage that effected users world wide February - April 2020 (3-4 outages in total); (3) December 2021 - Azure Active Directory outage locked people out of Azure and Outlook for several hours. (4) July 2022 - half-day outage for exchange, teams, sharepoint for most users. Same span outlook and exchange were down much like this last event for several hours. (5) Jan & Feb 2023 several outages for globoal Microsoft Outlook and network events.
That's not even all of the events in the last 5-6 years.
Optimizely, NSA network, and FAA mostly would have been under reported and or ignored by the general public.
I'm not saying this time couldn't be different this time, but what is the thesis? AI, foreign actors, incompetence?
"I don't know what, but something is clearly happening" is fear talking not rational thinking. Not all dots require connections. If you had full awareness of all the wild things that go on in one day, the amount of correlation you could draw from that if you're trying to tell a story would be pretty salacious.
But correlation != ____________
I agree that correlation doesn't imply causation. At the same time, I think an increase in uncommon events over a relatively short period of time does increase the chance that they are correlated.
Does it increase it enough to make it plausible or likely? No clue. But we've seen similar in Europe, and the consensus among intelligence/military analysts seems to be that Russia and Europe are in a non-military conflict of some sort.
It might be just bad luck here, or the start of something similar.
I don't think it's a stretch to say that some number of services go down every day and we don't hear or care about them. Three or four services going down and/or being attacked over a few days is only a pattern if it's actually different from before vs. you're just more aware about them.
united: https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/united-airlines-system-...
Because then you have to define the "major" and "short" in "major outages in a short timespan", in such a way that
A. Includes all four of those B. When applied to the past, would actually, meaningfully differ from the status quo (How often can something happen before it's alarming? Once a decade? Twice as often as that? Half as often?) C. Isn't a clear overfit, threading the needle to meet A and B, but is actually robust against perturbations.
You will likely be right that this is a meaningful period, simply from the flights being grounded and the Microsoft outage, both meaningfully unusual events, but it's very easy to make a fairly challenging assessment seem simple if you just arbitrarily choose things to count on your fingers.
'Mr Bond, they have a saying in Chicago:
"Once is happenstance. Twice is coincidence. The third time it's enemy action."
[From the original Ian Fleming novel]'
After the very deadly crash in Spain a few weeks ago...
You don't need a spy if the target self-sabotages.
AI-accelerated attacks, I think most of the cybersecurity ones are attributable to that exploiting previous incompetences. But the flight grounding and microsoft outages? Looks more like direct incompetence to me
Either way I think the takeaway is that we've been slacking for a long time and now we have something that doesn't need man-hours, caffeine, and obsessive human focus to take advantage of that fact. At least for those of us who have been in the field for a while there's lots of work cleaning up these messes for the foreseeable future but I been on calls with peers of mine in infosec who have definitely been losing valuable sleep and health over it
Of what?
What are you talking about?
The question I asked you is a specific one and it has a specific answer.
It's easy to spot patterns when paranoid.
If four politicians die on the same day of heart attacks, maybe they're unrelated. Maybe they're chemical assassinations.
Same here.
> Because we don't know they're unrelated.
They might be related! But the burden of proof is not on the null case.
While this rule doesn't apply to the NSA, speculation that recent down time from these U.S. companies being caused by state-sponsored cyber warfare seems unlikely.
News professionals would never be granted "need to know", and therefore would never be granted any level of secure access at all.
AI cyberattacks, foreign interference, and Ghost in the Shell type stuff sounds cooler though.
For instance, I have heard that Iranians have developed rather sophisticated cyber-warfare capabilities. I don't know if that is true, and if true, I don't know how likely it would be that they would have reached capabilities to cause the observed outages. But even if you assume that the probability (or rather degree of belief) is quite small but still realistic, say between 0.1 and 10 percents, than considering the current situation it might be absolutely rational to see it likely that they are behind these outages. The full analysis requires estimation of the probability that this is all just a coincidence, and of other major "non-coincidental" branches. But one can do this at various levels of precision and explicitly observe how the output depends on the priors and the estimated probabilities (and therefore, on the assumptions).
First of all, I have not said that just assigning arbitrary probabilities sheds much light on the matter. Rather, what I alluded to, is that even rough estimates might often shed a lot of light on the topic. The Bayesian formulation helps to separate the problem into relevant parts, make the relative importance and interdependence of various factors that enter the reasoning clearer, and makes the assumptions more explicit. But in my post I have not really explained anything; I have just pointed to a tool somebody interested might use to critically assess similar issues. So yes, if you took it away, the post would lack an important part of its message, namely a pointer to a framework that the OP (or anyone interested) might find useful. However, I do not plan to give a treatise on Bayesian analysis in a HN post.
As for the other angles of your post: 1. Yes, the usage of the framework absolutely can shed light on many matters of this kind. What is your background? How much experience do you have with statistics or inference in general? There are many good sources where you can learn about these methods. A somewhat controversial one, but freely accessible, is E.T. Jaynes' Probability Theory, which actually directly addresses some aspects of what I spoke about. 2."it just seems to make explicit what everyone already does implicitly" People apply very bad judgement to matters like these all the time, this forum included. And even if people all used those things implicitly (which often they don't) it would still be worthwhile since it allows one to inspect the argument and find flaws or observe what are the dependencies on various assumptions.
I saw some speculation here [1] that it might be the root cause.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genesis_Mission
[1] https://substack.com/@thedreydossier/note/c-389611426
It's a big change so hiccups are expected.
They don't. This administration thought they could Venezuela Iran from the air.
Even more importantly, when these pretextual actions occur, everyone interprets them the same way and agrees that the secretly-planned action is now the one we must take.
It has come to my attention that the political elites and the Epstein class simply do as they please with virtually no consequences.
That's basically what's happening to the US right now. It is corruption from the Oval Office all the way down. Pardons are being openly sold. The news was manipulated ("a ceasefire is imminent") to profit off the oil markets. Stock trades on insider information abound. All of this is an inevitable consequence from a Supreme Court who manufactured out of thin air substantial criminal immunity for the president. This built on other decisions where this Court in particular just could not see corruption (eg Snyder v. United States [1]).
In the private sector literally nobody is ever punished for cost-cutting on systems to the point that they break. In fact, they're rewarded for it. It's entshittification from the CEOs all the way down.
We'll probably find as more of these incidents happen that AI code was written and reviewed by another AI, never tested and deployed to production. Foreign actors will be blamed, Congress will be blamed, etc. As an aside, the DoT is asking for $50 billion after the FAA outage (the worst in 25 years). Then Representative Mullin voted against $25 billion for the FAA in the Infrastructure Investment and Jobs Act in 2021 [2].
Now the administration wants to sell this narrative that they've been hacked. No, they're just corrupt and everything sucks as an inevitable result. Everything is shit. Nobody is hacking us.
I honestly don't know how we get out of this but we need a hard reset of some sort. One such hard reset was the French Revolution. There are an awful lot of people who need to spend the rest of their lives in jail, penniless.
[1]: https://us.transparency.org/news/supreme-court-undercuts-fed...
[2]: https://heritageaction.com/scorecard/members/M001190/117
none of these systems are even vaguely similar
Or is it close to a large corporation network built on MSFT stack?
https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
[0] https://www.craigslist.org/view/d/dallas-dallas-redditors-ge...
Reddit is done. I'm so glad I got perma-banned by their AI mod. Though the meat-space mods lifted the ban on appeal, I had a long enough interval that I unwound all engagement. I found reddit right after they launched and have spent a lot of time over the last 20 years on various subs. That's all over now.
I'm pretty sure they were calling that network the NSANet back then; I assume it's gone through many generations of upgrade since then. I don't remember much about them as a customer, except that (a) we weren't supposed to mention their name, and (b) they were running a horribly old version of the switch firmware. My understanding was that they literally tested stuff for years before deploying it.
It was a long time ago, and I was just a summer hire, so I could have this wrong; in addition things may have changed in the intervening 40 years.
It’s ass backwards.
The entire process is about compliance, the actual security is totally ignored.
One vendor I spoke to was scouring eBay for old Juniper VPN appliances that still had some ancient firmware that could no longer be “downgraded to” on new ones.
Notably, this old firmware included the back door used by the Chinese government that was trivially exploitable! [1]
Why that version!?
“Because that specific point release was certified years ago, and they never updated the certification subsequently.” was the almost verbatim explanation!
It’s insane, but that’s how government drones think. You can’t snap them out of it, they’re unable to comprehend any other way of doing things.
Details like “security is a treadmill, you have to keep moving” just doesn’t compute.
[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dual_EC_DRBG
But to your point if somebody like North Korea did it, they wouldn't brag about it but they'd be talking quietly to their friends and maybe even taking orders for the next target.
No. You might be able to conjure some scenario up, but the answer is no. And that is the basis for classifying things.
And further, there's a public interest in knowing if one of the premier intelligence agencies is so dysfunctional that they cannot even keep their computers connected.
Like the United Airlines thing yesterday, the moment I got to the article it said "was down for a few hours" but the post was still just something about United Airlines network being offline
If the network was one of those no-fail important ones (think NORAD stuff) then nobody would be talking about it as doing so would be treasonous. So, at most, this is a less-important internal network. It will probably be back up by end of business.
> The frequency illusion, also known as the Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, is a cognitive bias in which a person notices a specific concept, word, or product more frequently after recently becoming aware of it.
Or at least it is very similar.
[0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Frequency_illusion
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gatwick_Airport_drone_incident
>> Flap, originally a military term to describe a "period of panic or chaos", is used by ufologists to describe surges of sightings in one geographical area. Longer surges spanning multiple countries may be called waves. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/UFO_flap
Anything the catches the public's collective conscious, the media is there to stoke it into piles of ad dollars.
It's extremely profitable to write stories telling social media pitchfork mobs how correct they are. Influencers have been catching onto this game in the last decade too, and went from "here is what is actually going on" contrarians to "here is what is actually going on" agenda towing. It just pays so much more, and people trust you more (because people naturally trust those who tell them they are right).
Including NSA Net? How often does it fall down?
> We are probably only hearing about this because of the coincidence of the other recent network failures
This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time. Which also hints that NSA Net failures happen with some kind of regularity and that that news orgs had been getting wind of it.
I suspect that the opposite is true. That it's rare to unheard of for NSA Net to fail like this and rare for a news org to get wind of something so deeply protected.
I rather doubt they have a public status page.
> This seems to be an explanation for why the press is covering it - this time.
That's one possibility. Another is it goes down sometimes, but that morale in the administration has sunk to where it gets leaked.
I understand the skepticism, and I certainly don’t think we should go down a rabbit hole of conspiracy theories. But shouldn’t we also be a little skeptical of dismissing these events so quickly? Is it unreasonable to at least consider the possibility that they’re not entirely coincidental, or to wonder why so many seem to be taking place in the US?
Companies have been wide open in all sorts of ways for decades, and basically just surviving by flying under the radar of script kiddies.
That changed. Now script kiddies or average criminal orgs feel more able to just pick their targets, and it's an extremely target rich environment.
That a lot of businesses are finally taking drastic action sort of tells you how much they were willingly ignoring the issue previously. Everything everywhere was very insecure. It was just surviving from a lack of attackers.
Top level management, like investor level, still thinks this is just something to be fixed by applying a new magic word too, like "buy another security scanner" or "just use AI to fix the problem"
However, AI works like a speedy intern who hasn't yet got to grips with the whole codebase, and sometimes makes assumptions. That's mostly because the codebase is usually bigger than the context window, so it is 'writing blind'.
https://knowyourmeme.com/sensitive/memes/glowie-glowposting
Not unlike Bloomberg terminals…dos era UI but does the job well
I'm getting Feb 2020 vibes. I don't know what's going on, but this feels like more than just some routine outages going on.
So far this fall, none of my systems have gone haywire (yet!), so I forecast that we'll be OK.
"If you don't read the news you're uninformed, if you do read the news you're misinformed"
The sentiment is quite old, however. Thomas Jefferson wrote in 1807: ...the man who never looks into a newspaper is better informed than he who reads them; inasmuch as he who knows nothing is nearer to truth than he whose mind is filled with falsehoods & errors.
Where it gets interesting is the "Exclusive" part of the headline. Like somebody else said, any other source would either have to have access to people similar to CNN's "six people familiar with the matter" or else reference CNN.
The fact that Reuters amplified the story (and attributed it to CNN) gives it a little more weight.
Allowing our infrastructure to be manufactured elsewhere, maintained by companies who struggle to retain top talent, and overseen by folks out of touch with cutting edge threats, and funded on annual budget cycles by legislators even more out-of-touch ... is a seemingly insurmountable set of obstacles.
Trump is headed to China for a meeting with Xi and Putin.
We have 3 carriers off the coast of Iran and (despite Trump's pleas) NATO is essentially pushing their boot into Putin's neck w/ continued Ukrainian strikes on Russian oil infra.
I've seen a few takes from L3 Harris / FAA employees calling the official line about the ATC issue bunk and there are 3 other major issues in the last week, now this NSA outage - curious if these incidents could be the BRICS axis flexing their own cybermuscles (independently in multiple separate attacks with carefully placed assets) ahead of their meeting with Trump in China?
An interesting geopolitical Mexican standoff, if true.
I'm not claiming this is true. I'm literally pulling it out of my rear with little context beyond a bunch of random news stories and X posts, it's pure pedestrian speculation / curiosity.
Would love someone steeped in national security / geopolitics (like: professionally as their job, not armchair analysts) to offer their take on this.
Is this a dumb, naive theory?
I know it's not the thrust of your post, but I see this or similar framing a lot, and I feel compelled to point out that Putin can end the strikes on his oil infrastructure at any time by ending the war he started by invading another country.
Historically he's chosen to go about things differently, which I guess is part of what is tickling the pattern matching part of my brain here.
If that were the case buddy, there would be Apaches stationed in Moscow now.
Wonder what happened in 2014 that might have led to this?
What is your point? Obama admitted to interfering in Ukraine 2014.
I'm not sure about naive or dumb but you might review your POV regarding this.
My complete POV, FWIW:
* From a purely moral / ethical standpoint: it is good that this is happening, Russia "deserves" this and brought it upon themselves.
* This nonetheless has geopolitical implications. The less oil Russia has to sell to China, the more buy pressure there is elsewhere, the higher the price of oil is generally and thus the higher competition for resources / tensions are between great powers.
* Ukraine is doing a lot of the heavy lifting in many areas themselves these days, NATO could honestly be doing more. However: what Ukraine is able to do themselves does owe something to the financial and material support they have enjoyed (historically from both the US and NATO, currently more from NATO only) in that they are able to allocate their own efforts with according relative "ease"
* It makes sense to me that, given the US' power within NATO, Russia and its BRICS partners would try to apply pressure to the US to encourage NATO to provide even LESS support to Ukraine (or outright become antagonistic against Ukraine, to the extent we aren't already) in whatever way they could.
What revisions to my POV can you suggest?
* Russia could end these strikes and this war tomorrow if they wanted to.
I don't know how it could be proven either, I'm just curious if it is plausible or even likely from the perspective of someone who knows more than me about NatSec / geopolitical issues.
* FAA
* Banks
* Optimizely malware
* nsanet
* Apple
Time to panic?
NSANet is one of the most locked down, observed and monitored networks on the planet
Did you try sending it via outlook.com?
Someone who wants to launch a Y2K-style hardening business (LLMS to look for problems, humans+LLMs to fix them) could really make bank right now. Maybe there will be a cuple in the next YC batch.
It sure is fun living in a world of zero trust.
Just like good crypto must survive robust cryptanalysis, good network security needs to be robust even when adversaries know the network exists (and perhaps even where in physical space key nodes are located).
That being said: the network being down isn't something that immediately makes me worried in the near term. "Turn it off" is a better first response than "observe if anything seems weird" for communications channels that prioritize secrecy over availability.
And the cost to fix this is gonna be $12-billion. No wait, $30-billion. Fuuck it, make it $50-billion. And give it to me now or else!!!
A couple of incidents, spin the media, let them be terrified
Put your cape on, come to save the world
Then tax it, regulate it, sprinkle some tariffs, nuclear winter, external enemies, china, don't forget about china
Then we police the world and our AI is the only one with the seal of "liberty"
From the black book of politiks, watch the sheeple, rejoice
Definitely just a big coincidence due to firing people, upgrades, and AI.
...maybe.
Seriously though at what point does this become justifiably suspicious?
The truth lies somewhere in the middle. My theory: someone figured out how to bring down each network. And is progressively breaking each system to help developers fix their security holes. Given enough breaks, we will figure out their modus operandi. And then figure out who they are.
Or something even more conspiratorial: us govt is halting each system to install back doors.
(I'm not saying the dems would do better, i'm saying we all need to stop voting for old men in primaries because they are more "electable")
Also consider that the media absolutely loves to run any story it can find about a network going down right now because it causes fear, and fear gets clicks. Now think about how many major networks have a problem in a given week. You just never hear about them until now.
No I don't. Why would you risk your career and potentially your freedom to leak a report about enemy action, in which doing so could potentially harm your country too?
[0] https://harvardlawreview.org/print/vol-127/the-leaky-leviath...
https://www.cnn.com/2026/11/16/politics/us-intelligence-iran...
No and that was the purpose of DOGE
(yes that quote was separated from its context with some malice)
I doubt this is the case, but since we're talking about conspiracy theories: this looks more like things breaking by accident as things are shimmed for control by a third party and less like a focused attack.
It's exactly like the media reporting every aviation notice after an airplane crash. Leading people to speculate "why is everything broken right now!" even though it's the normal course of business, they're only just noticing it now because they're being told to notice it.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Genesis_Mission
https://substack.com/@thedreydossier/note/c-389611426
https://www.whitehouse.gov/presidential-actions/2025/11/laun...
If more people misspell than not, then what do the predictive statistics result in?
It peaked at early mature swype, and has been downhill since then.
Nice try, foreign hacker
> according to six people
https://www.nsa.gov/portals/75/documents/news-features/decla...